Class 9 Science Chapter 5: Exploring Mixtures and their Separation
- 5 topics
- 200 MCQs
- 40 short answers
- 20 long answers
- 110 flashcards
- 20 games
- ~200 min read
- English
Classifying Mixtures, and What a Solution Is
Some mixtures look the same wherever you sample them and some do not, and that single test splits every mixture into two families. A homogeneous one is a solution, made of a solute dissolved in a solvent; a heterogeneous one shows its parts and often settles out.
What you will be able to do
- Distinguish a homogeneous mixture from a heterogeneous one by its composition.
- Give everyday examples of each kind of mixture.
- Identify the solute and the solvent in a given solution.
- Describe the group activity that separates three mixtures by their behaviour.
- Explain why separating mixtures matters in industry and in medicine.
Key points
A mixture of sugar and water has the same make-up everywhere in it, so once it is stirred properly the first sip tastes exactly as sweet as the last.
Such a mixture is called a homogeneous mixture, and another name for it is a solution; vinegar, which is acetic acid in water, and fizzy drinks, which hold carbon dioxide in water, are further examples.
A solution stays homogeneous, which is to say its uniformity does not break down while it stands.
Stir sand into water and the result is nothing like uniform: the grains can be picked out by eye and drop to the bottom as time passes, which makes this a heterogeneous mixture.
Oil poured into water raises the same question, and the answer is plain enough once you look at the two layers.
A solution forms when a solute, which is whatever gets dissolved, goes into a solvent, which is whatever does the dissolving; in sugar water the sugar is the solute and the water the solvent.
Three beakers make the differences visible: salt stirred into water, chalk powder stirred into water, and a few drops of milk stirred into water.
The three are tested in three ways, by looking for visible particles, by shining a laser through the side and watching from a right angle, and by pouring each through filter paper to see whether anything stays behind.
Leaving the beakers undisturbed for a few minutes adds a fourth test, since settling separates one of the three from the others.
Never look straight into a laser beam, as the damage it can do to an eye cannot be undone.
Techniques for separating mixtures lie behind things as different as turning tall green sugarcane into white sugar crystals and testing a few drops of blood for malaria.
Full explanation
Why Separating Mixtures Matters
Have you ever wondered how sweet, white crystals of sugar come out of tall, green sugarcane plants? Or how doctors detect diseases such as malaria using just a few drops of blood?
Both rest on techniques for separating mixtures. From industrial work such as sugar production to life-saving medical tests, this science turns up everywhere.
You already know something about mixtures and a few simple ways to separate them. This chapter goes further, into their properties, their behaviour, and the range of techniques used on them.
Two Families of Mixture
Everything starts with one question: is the mixture the same all the way through?
When it is: homogeneous
A mixture of sugar and water has a uniform composition throughout. Stir it well and it is equally sweet in the first sip and in the last — the make-up does not vary from the top of the glass to the bottom.
Such a mixture is called a homogeneous mixture, or a solution.
Other examples:
- vinegar — acetic acid in water,
- aerated drinks such as soda — carbon dioxide in water.
And one important point: a solution always remains homogeneous. Its uniformity does not break down while it stands.
When it is not: heterogeneous
Now stir sand into water. The result is not uniform. The sand particles are easily visible, and they settle with time, dropping to the bottom of the container.
Such a mixture is called a heterogeneous mixture.
What about oil and water? Pour one into the other and watch what happens. Can you think of other heterogeneous mixtures from around the house?
Solutions, Solutes and Solvents
Solutions are homogeneous mixtures. They are prepared when a solute is mixed with a solvent:
- the solute is the substance that gets dissolved,
- the solvent is the substance that dissolves the solute.
Stir sugar into water and the sugar is the solute, the water the solvent.
Which leaves a question worth carrying forward: how much of each is there, and can the answer be put as a figure? The next topic takes it up.
Activity 5.1: Three Beakers, Three Mixtures
The class divides into three groups. Each group makes up its mixture in something clear and colourless — a plain tumbler will do, or a 100 mL beaker.
| Group | Mixture | Label |
|---|---|---|
| A | One spatula of common salt in 50 mL of water, stirred well | A |
| B | One spatula of chalk powder in 50 mL of water, stirred well | B |
| C | A few drops of milk in 50 mL of water, stirred well | C |
Four tests
1. Look. Are the particles visible in each mixture? Record what you see.
2. Shine a laser through. Direct the light from a laser pointer through each beaker, and observe from the side, in a direction perpendicular to the beam. Record your observations.
Safety first: Never turn your eyes along the beam itself. An eye injury from a laser is one that cannot be repaired.
3. Leave them standing. Predict what you would see in each beaker after a few minutes undisturbed.
4. Filter. Rig up the filtration apparatus and put each mixture through it on its own. Does anything stay behind on the paper?
What the activity shows
Based on those observations, are these the same type of mixture, or different types?
They are indeed different types. Salt water behaves one way, chalk in water another, and milk in water a third. Working out exactly how is what the rest of the chapter is for.
Three Questions to Carry Forward
The chapter opens with three puzzles worth keeping in mind:
- Why does muddy water clear from the top down if left standing, while milk never does?
- How is evaporation different from boiling?
- Why do shafts of light show up where sun comes through gaps in thick foliage?
Each one gets answered before the chapter is done.
Concepts and terms
A mixture whose make-up is the same throughout, so that any sample taken from it matches any other. Another name for it is a solution.
A mixture that is not uniform. Its parts can often be seen, and some of them may drop to the bottom if the mixture is left standing.
The substance that gets dissolved when a solution is made. Sugar plays this part in sugar water.
The substance that does the dissolving. Water plays this part in sugar water, and in a great many other solutions.
Pouring a mixture through filter paper to find out whether anything is held back on it. What stays behind is called the residue.
Did you know
Turning tall green sugarcane plants into sweet white crystals of sugar is a separation problem, solved by the techniques this chapter is about.
Doctors can detect diseases such as malaria from just a few drops of blood, using methods built on the same science.
Fizzy drinks are solutions too, with carbon dioxide gas playing the part that sugar plays in sugar water.
Memory tricks
Telling the two families apart — Same all through, or not — If every sample matches every other, the mixture is homogeneous. If the parts can be told apart, it is heterogeneous.
Solute and solvent — The smaller one dissolves, the larger one does the dissolving — Sugar disappears into water rather than the other way round, so sugar is the solute and water the solvent.
The first sip test — First sip, last sip — A properly stirred sugar solution tastes equally sweet at the beginning and at the end, which is exactly what uniform make-up means.
Practice MCQs with answers (40)
- A heterogeneous, since the parts can be told apart by eye
- B a residue, being whatever the filter paper holds back
- C homogeneous, which is also what the word solution means
- D a solvent, being the part that does the dissolving
Show answer
Why:
Another name for such a mixture is a solution.
- A A residue
- B A solution
- C A solvent
- D A solute
Show answer
Why:
The two terms are used interchangeably.
- A water, because it is present in the larger amount
- B both together, since each dissolves into the other
- C neither, since no dissolving takes place in this mixture
- D sugar, because it is the part that gets dissolved
Show answer
Why:
Water is the solvent, since it does the dissolving.
- A sugar
- B the sweetness
- C water
- D the container
Show answer
Why:
Sugar is the solute, since it gets dissolved.
- A carbon dioxide in water
- B acetic acid in water
- C common salt in water
- D chalk powder in water
Show answer
Why:
Carbon dioxide in water gives an aerated drink instead.
- A acetic acid in water
- B sand in water
- C oil in water
- D carbon dioxide in water
Show answer
Why:
A gas serves as the solute here.
- A homogeneous, since stirring spreads the grains evenly about
- B a solution, with the sand serving as its solute
- C heterogeneous, since the grains stay in view and settle
- D perfectly uniform, provided the stirring goes on long enough
Show answer
Why:
The particles are visible and settle with time.
- A The residue, whatever the filter paper has held back
- B The solute, being the part that has been dissolved
- C The solvent, being the part that does the dissolving
- D The solution, being the whole uniform mixture together
Show answer
Why:
Its presence or absence helps sort the mixtures.
- A An opaque metal container
- B A colourless, transparent tumbler or a 100 mL beaker
- C A coloured plastic bottle
- D A wide shallow dish
Show answer
Why:
The light has to be able to pass through it.
- A 100 mL
- B 50 mL
- C 500 mL
- D 5 mL
Show answer
Why:
The beaker itself may hold 100 mL.
- A Its composition is the same in every part of the glass
- B Sugar rises to the top as the glass is emptied
- C The tongue cannot detect changes in sweetness
- D The sugar has not yet begun to dissolve
Show answer
Why:
That uniformity is exactly what homogeneous means.
- A Sand is a solvent rather than a solute
- B Stirring makes any mixture heterogeneous
- C Nothing is wrong; hard stirring does make it uniform
- D The particles stay visible and settle out, so the mixture is not uniform
Show answer
Why:
Effort does not change which family a mixture belongs to.
- A A solution contains no solvent at all
- B A solution always remains homogeneous as it stands
- C A solution cannot be poured through filter paper
- D A solution is never made from a solid and a liquid
Show answer
Why:
Its uniformity does not break down over time.
- A Every solution is a mixture, but not every mixture is a solution
- B Every mixture is a solution, but not every solution is a mixture
- C Solutions and mixtures are entirely separate categories
- D The two words mean exactly the same in all cases
Show answer
Why:
Solution names the homogeneous family within mixtures.
- A The beam is invisible from any other direction
- B Looking into the beam directly can cause eye damage that cannot be undone
- C The beaker blocks the beam completely from the front
- D Side observation makes the mixture settle faster
Show answer
Why:
The observation is made perpendicular to the beam.
- A Water is the solute and carbon dioxide the solvent in soda
- B Acetic acid is the solvent and water the solute in vinegar
- C Carbon dioxide is the solute and water the solvent in soda
- D Sugar is the solvent and water the solute in sugar water
Show answer
Why:
The solvent is whatever does the dissolving.
- A It allows the water to evaporate completely
- B It makes the particles in every beaker dissolve
- C It shows which of the mixtures separates out on standing
- D It is only a way of passing time between tests
Show answer
Why:
Settling is one of the behaviours that sorts the three.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
A solution always remains homogeneous, so it does not separate.
- A 1, 2 and 3
- B 1 and 2 only
- C 1 and 3 only
- D 2 and 3 only
Show answer
Why:
Looking, shining, standing and filtering are the four tests.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Statement 3 describes the solute, not the solvent.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Both are true. Naming which part is which does not explain why the taste is the same throughout.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
No amount of stirring dissolves sand, so the assertion is false. The reason describes what actually happens.
- A a homogeneous mixture, since both are liquids
- B a solution, with oil as the solute
- C a heterogeneous mixture, since the two form separate layers
- D not a mixture at all
Show answer
Why:
The two do not blend into one uniform liquid.
- A Heating each mixture to boiling point
- B Checking whether particles are visible
- C Passing a laser beam through the beaker
- D Filtering each mixture separately
Show answer
Why:
The fourth test is leaving the beakers undisturbed.
- A Because gases cannot form heterogeneous mixtures
- B Because the gas escapes, leaving pure liquid behind
- C Because a gas is always the solvent in such a mixture
- D Because the mixture is homogeneous, which is what the word means
Show answer
Why:
Soda holds carbon dioxide as its solute.
- A It is coloured rather than colourless
- B It has been stirred for a long time
- C Its parts can be made out, and some may be settling to the bottom
- D It is held in a transparent container
Show answer
Why:
Visibility of the particles is the first clue.
- A Removing salt from the sea by boiling it away
- B Getting white sugar crystals from tall green sugarcane plants
- C Separating iron filings from sulphur powder
- D Purifying air by passing it through water
Show answer
Why:
Detecting malaria from a few drops of blood is the other.
- A It must be a mixture of sand and water
- B It is likely to be a solution
- C Its particles must be very large
- D It cannot be a mixture at all
Show answer
Why:
Both behaviours are what a homogeneous mixture shows.
- A So that the mixture stays cooler while it stands
- B So that the mixture can be filtered more easily
- C So that the solute dissolves faster in the solvent
- D So that both the particles and the laser beam can be seen through it
Show answer
Why:
Two of the four tests depend on being able to see inside.
- A Why one is white and the other brown
- B Why one can be drunk and the other cannot
- C Why suspended particles settle in one over time but not in the other
- D Why both leave a residue on filter paper
Show answer
Why:
The answer comes later in the chapter.
- A The beam cannot be switched off once started
- B The mixture cannot be separated again
- C The observation cannot be repeated
- D The damage cannot be put right afterwards
Show answer
Why:
Which is why the warning is given before the activity begins.
- A Classify the mixture, then name the solute and solvent if it is a solution
- B Name the solute first, then decide whether a mixture exists
- C Filter every mixture before deciding what it contains
- D Assume all mixtures are solutions unless they are coloured
Show answer
Why:
Solute and solvent are terms that only apply to solutions.
- A Taste measures the exact amount of solute present
- B Only homogeneous mixtures have any taste at all
- C A matching taste from top to bottom shows the make-up does not vary
- D Taste reveals whether a residue will form on filtering
Show answer
Why:
It is a rough test, but it tests the right property.
- A Group A
- B Group C
- C Group B
- D No group did
Show answer
Why:
Group A used salt and Group B used chalk powder.
- A Group B
- B Group A
- C Group C
- D All three groups
Show answer
Why:
Group C used milk and Group A used common salt.
- A They are the only use chemistry has outside a laboratory
- B They make every mixture homogeneous
- C They underpin processes from sugar production to medical testing
- D They replace the need to classify mixtures at all
Show answer
Why:
Industry at one end and medicine at the other.
- A One spatula
- B One gram exactly
- C Ten spatulas
- D Half a beaker
Show answer
Why:
Group B adds one spatula of chalk powder in the same way.
- A Because it cannot be poured from one vessel to another
- B Because its solute eventually turns into solvent
- C Because it is prepared from only one substance
- D Because its uniformity does not break down as it stands
Show answer
Why:
This is precisely what a settling mixture fails to do.
- A Solvent — the substance that gets dissolved
- B Residue — the substance that does the dissolving
- C Solution — a mixture that settles on standing
- D Solute — the substance that gets dissolved
Show answer
Why:
The solvent is what does the dissolving.
- A Three beakers are needed to make enough liquid to filter
- B Each group must have a different vessel to work in
- C The three mixtures combine at the end of the activity
- D Comparing their behaviour is what reveals that mixtures come in different types
Show answer
Why:
One mixture alone would show nothing by comparison.
Important short questions (8)
It is a mixture whose composition is uniform throughout, so that any part of it matches any other. Vinegar, which is acetic acid in water, and aerated drinks such as soda, which hold carbon dioxide in water, are two further examples.
Because it is equally sweet in the first sip and in the last. That sameness of taste from one end of the glass to the other shows that the composition does not vary from one part of the mixture to another.
Because it is not the same throughout. You can pick out the grains by eye, and left alone they drop to the bottom. Stirring does not change either of these behaviours.
The solute is the substance that gets dissolved and the solvent is the substance that dissolves it. Stir sugar into water and the sugar is the solute, the water the solvent.
It means the uniformity of a solution does not break down as it stands. Unlike a mixture whose particles settle to the bottom, a solution keeps the same composition throughout however long it is left undisturbed.
Group A stirs one spatula of common salt into 50 mL of water, Group B one spatula of chalk powder, and Group C a few drops of milk, each in a colourless transparent tumbler or 100 mL beaker. The warning is never to look directly into the laser beam, since it can cause irreversible eye damage.
Looking at each mixture shows whether any particles are visible. Shining a laser through the beaker and observing from the side, perpendicular to the beam, shows how each mixture handles light. Leaving the beakers undisturbed shows which mixtures settle. Filtering each one shows whether a residue is left on the filter paper.
A solution is not something separate from a mixture: it is a mixture, of the homogeneous kind. So every solution is a mixture, while a mixture is only a solution if its composition is uniform throughout. Sand in water is a mixture but not a solution.
Long answer questions (4)
Everything turns on one question: is the mixture the same all the way through?
A mixture of sugar and water has a uniform composition throughout. Stirred well, it is equally sweet in the first sip and in the last, so the make-up does not vary from the top of the glass to the bottom. Such a mixture is called a homogeneous mixture, and another name for it is a solution. Vinegar, which is acetic acid in water, and aerated drinks such as soda, which hold carbon dioxide in water, belong to the same family.
One further point holds for all of them: a solution always remains homogeneous, so its uniformity does not break down as it stands.
A stirred mixture of sand and water behaves quite differently. It is not uniform at all. The sand particles are easily visible in the water, and they settle with time. We call such a mixture a heterogeneous mixture, and no amount of stirring will change that.
Oil poured into water raises the same question and is answered the same way, since the two sit in separate layers rather than blending into one uniform liquid.
The evidence to quote is therefore of three kinds: whether the composition is the same everywhere, whether the particles can be seen, and whether anything settles on standing.
Split the class three ways; each group makes up its mixture in something clear and colourless, a plain tumbler or a 100 mL beaker. Group A stirs one spatula of common salt into 50 mL of water, Group B one spatula of chalk powder, and Group C a few drops of milk. Each beaker is labelled with its group letter.
The first test is simply to look. Are the particles visible in each mixture? What is seen is recorded before anything else is done.
The second test uses light. The beam from a laser pointer is directed through each beaker, and observed from the side, perpendicular to the beam. Here the safety warning applies: never look directly into the laser beam, since it can cause irreversible eye damage.
The third test is patience. Each group predicts what would be seen in its beaker if it were left undisturbed for a few minutes, which brings out whether anything settles.
The fourth test uses a filtration apparatus. Each mixture is filtered separately and the filter paper examined for any residue left behind.
Taken together the four tests answer the question the activity was set up to ask. The three mixtures behave differently, so they are not all of one kind but belong to different types, and the rest of the chapter works out what those types are.
Solutions are homogeneous mixtures, which means their composition is uniform throughout.
They are prepared when a solute is mixed with a solvent. The solute is the substance that gets dissolved, and the solvent is the substance that dissolves the solute. Stir sugar into water and the sugar is the solute, the water the solvent.
The parts need not both be solids or both liquids. In vinegar the solute is acetic acid, a liquid, and in an aerated drink such as soda the solute is carbon dioxide, a gas, while water serves as the solvent in each case.
The word solution names a family within mixtures rather than an alternative to them. Every solution is a mixture, since it is made of more than one substance put together without either losing its identity. But not every mixture is a solution, because a mixture only qualifies if its composition is uniform throughout. Sand in water is a mixture and not a solution.
This is why the terms solute and solvent can only be applied once a mixture has been classified as homogeneous. Asking which part of a sand and water mixture is the solute has no sensible answer.
The chapter opens with two puzzles: how a tall green cane yields white sugar crystals, and how a doctor can find malaria in a couple of drops of blood.
Both are separation problems. Many everyday activities are made possible by techniques based on the science of separating mixtures, and from industrial work such as sugar production to life-saving medical tests, that separation plays a real part in daily life.
The chapter builds on what is already known about mixtures and a few simple ways of separating them, going further into their properties, their behaviour, and the range of techniques used on them.
Three further questions are set at the start to be carried through. Why does muddy water clear from the top down if left standing, while milk never does? How is evaporation different from boiling? And why do shafts of light show up where sun comes through gaps in thick foliage?
Each of those is answered before the chapter is finished, and each depends on understanding what kind of mixture is involved. That is why the first thing the chapter does is classify mixtures into the homogeneous and the heterogeneous.
Flashcards (22)
Play this topic
- Mixtures and Their Parts
- True or False: Classifying Mixtures
- Fill the Gaps: Mixtures
- Unscramble: Mixtures and Solutions
Concentration of a Solution
Getting the proportion right is what separates a life-saving rehydration drink from ordinary sugar water, and a useful pesticide spray from one that ruins a field. Concentration puts a number on that proportion, and three percentage methods cover the cases that come up.
What you will be able to do
- Define the concentration of a solution.
- Explain why the right proportion matters, using rehydration solution and pesticide spray.
- Calculate mass by mass percentage for a given solution.
- Calculate mass by volume and volume by volume percentages.
- Choose the appropriate percentage method for a given situation.
Key points
Concentration is the amount of solute dissolved in a stated amount of solvent, or of solution, and it is what fixes the proportion between the two.
ORS is a measured thing: set weights of salt and sugar into a set volume of water. Shift either the weights or the volume and you still have salt and sugar dissolved in water, but you no longer have ORS.
Not every sweet drink made at home or sold in a shop counts as ORS, however similar it may look.
Dilip Mahalanabis, an Indian paediatrician, was the first to develop and put into practice the treatment for dehydration brought on by illnesses such as diarrhoea and cholera.
The formulation he arrived at transformed rehydration therapy and has saved millions of lives since the World Health Organization took it up around the world.
Farmers spraying crops face the same problem, since too little pesticide may leave the crop unprotected while too much can harm the crop, the soil and the surroundings.
Concentration can be expressed in several ways, and the one taken up here is percentage, with the others left for higher grades.
Mass by mass percentage counts how many grams of solute sit in 100 grams of the whole solution, worked out as $\text{% m/m} = \frac{\text{mass of solute}}{\text{mass of solution}} \times 100$.
It suits homogeneous mixtures but serves heterogeneous ones too, such as milk powder and spice blends, and it is what labels on packaged foods use to declare their salt, sugar or protein.
Mass by volume percentage counts grams of solute in 100 millilitres of solution, written $\text{% m/v} = \frac{\text{mass of solute}}{\text{volume of solution}} \times 100$, and it is chosen where measuring out a liquid beats weighing it, as in medicines and laboratories.
Volume by volume percentage counts millilitres of solute in 100 millilitres of solution, written $\text{% v/v} = \frac{\text{volume of solute}}{\text{volume of solution}} \times 100$, and it is the method for two miscible liquids, as in perfumes, cosmetics and vinegar.
Dissolving 10 g of salt in 90 g of water gives a solution of total mass 100 g, so the mass by mass percentage works out at 10%.
Dissolving 5 g of glucose in water to make 100 mL of solution gives 5% m/v, the strength printed on a familiar glucose bottle.
Mixing 1 mL of liquid pesticide with enough water to reach 100 mL gives a spray of 1% v/v.
Industry usually writes weight by weight percentage, since weight and mass are treated as interchangeable in ordinary use, and the two figures come out numerically equal.
Full explanation
Why Proportion Matters
Solutions are made from a solute and a solvent. But in what proportion? And can that proportion be put into numbers?
It turns out a great deal depends on the answer.
Oral Rehydration Solution
ORS is a measured thing: set weights of salt and sugar into a set volume of water.
Alter the weights while keeping the water the same, or alter the water while keeping the weights, and what you end with is still salt and sugar dissolved in water — but it is not ORS.
Note: a sweet drink mixed at home, or bought in a shop, is not thereby ORS.
A pesticide spray
A farmer spraying a crop has the same problem: so much pesticide to so much water, and the proportion has to be right.
What happens otherwise?
- Too little pesticide may not protect the crops.
- Too much can damage the crops, the soil and the environment.
In both cases the same lesson holds: getting the proportion right always matters when preparing a solution.
The Definition
How much solute is carried by a stated quantity of solvent, or of the solution as a whole, is what we call its concentration.
Understanding it matters not only in science laboratories but in ordinary life — in medicine, agriculture, food, cosmetics, even while making a simple cup of tea.
Meet a Scientist: Dilip Mahalanabis
It was an Indian children's doctor, Dilip Mahalanabis, who first worked out such a treatment and got it into use against the water loss that diarrhoea and cholera cause.
The formula he arrived at changed how rehydration is done everywhere. After the World Health Organization popularised it worldwide, it has saved millions of lives.
Expressing Concentration
Concentration can be expressed in several ways. The common one taken up here is percentage; the other methods come in higher grades.
There are three main percentage methods.
A. Percentage by Mass (% m/m or % w/w)
This is commonly used for homogeneous mixtures. It reports the grams of solute carried in every 100 grams of finished solution.
$\text{Mass by mass percentage} = \dfrac{\text{Mass of solute}}{\text{Mass of solution}} \times 100$ — (5.1)
It is used for heterogeneous mixtures too, such as milk powder and spice mixtures. And it is the method behind the labels on packaged foods, telling you how much salt, sugar or protein is present.
Example 5.1
Salt weighing 10 g goes into 90 g of water. What is the percentage by mass?
- solute: 10 g of salt
- solvent: 90 g of water
- the solution therefore weighs 10 g + 90 g = 100 g
$\dfrac{10\ \text{g}}{100\ \text{g}} \times 100 = 10%\ \text{m/m}$
Notice the denominator: it is the solution, not the solvent. Dividing by 90 g would be wrong.
B. Mass by Volume Percentage (% m/v or % w/v)
It is the figure to reach for when a liquid is easier to measure out than to weigh — in medicine and in the laboratory, that is usually so. The 5% glucose solution is the familiar case.
It tells you how many grams of solute are present in 100 millilitres of solution.
$\text{Mass by volume percentage} = \dfrac{\text{Mass of solute}}{\text{Volume of solution}} \times 100$ — (5.2)
Example 5.2
Glucose weighing 5 g is made up with water to 100 mL. What is the concentration?
- Mass of the glucose (the solute) = 5 g
- Volume of solution = 100 mL
$\dfrac{5\ \text{g}}{100\ \text{mL}} \times 100 = 5%\ \text{m/v}$
C. Volume by Volume Percentage (% v/v)
This one is for two liquids that mix freely — scent, cosmetics, vinegar.
It tells you how many millilitres of solute are present in 100 millilitres of solution.
$\text{Volume by volume percentage} = \dfrac{\text{Volume of solute}}{\text{Volume of solution}} \times 100$ — (5.3)
Example 5.3
One millilitre of liquid pesticide is made up with water to 100 mL of spray for a rice field. What is the percentage by volume?
- Volume of pesticide (solute) = 1 mL
- Total volume of solution = 100 mL
$\dfrac{1\ \text{mL}}{100\ \text{mL}} \times 100 = 1%\ \text{v/v}$
Choosing Between the Three
| Method | Solute measured as | Solution measured as | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| % m/m | mass | mass | Packaged foods, milk powder, spice mixtures |
| % m/v | mass | volume | Medicines, laboratory solutions |
| % v/v | volume | volume | Perfumes, cosmetics, vinegar |
Weigh both, weigh one, measure both.
Note: The unit commonly used in industries is weight by weight percentage (% w/w), since weight and mass are generally used interchangeably. Numerically the two percentages come out to the same figure.
Pause and Ponder
Three problems to try:
- A talcum powder carries 4% m/m zinc oxide as an antiseptic. What weight of zinc oxide is there in a 300 g tin?
- You are told to mix two tablespoons of orange juice concentrate with water, making 150 mL of juice per person. Taking a tablespoon at 15 mL, what % v/v of concentrate is in the glass?
- Vinegar, which both preserves food and flavours it, runs at 5% v/v acetic acid. The undiluted acid is a liquid at full strength. How would you proceed to make vinegar from it?
Concepts and terms
The amount of solute dissolved in a stated amount of solvent or of solution. It is what fixes the proportion between the two, and getting it right matters in medicine, farming, food and cosmetics alike.
The grams of solute carried in every 100 grams of finished solution. Written % m/m or % w/w, and calculated as the mass of solute divided by the mass of solution, times 100.
How many grams of solute are present in 100 millilitres of solution. Written % m/v or % w/v, and used where measuring out a liquid is easier than weighing it.
How many millilitres of solute are present in 100 millilitres of solution. Written % v/v, and used when two miscible liquids are mixed together.
Two liquids that mix into one another to give a uniform solution. Their proportions are expressed by volume by volume percentage.
Did you know
Dilip Mahalanabis, an Indian paediatrician, formulated the rehydration solution that has since saved millions of lives around the world.
The same idea of concentration is at work in medicine, agriculture, food, cosmetics and even in making an ordinary cup of tea.
Mass by mass percentage is not reserved for solutions. Milk powder and spice blends are heterogeneous, and their composition is still declared this way.
Memory tricks
Picking the method — Weigh both, weigh one, measure both — Weigh solute and solution for % m/m, weigh the solute but measure the solution for % m/v, and measure both volumes for % v/v.
What the denominator is — Solution below, never solvent — All three formulas divide by the amount of the whole solution, not by the amount of solvent. 10 g of salt in 90 g of water divides by 100 g, not 90 g.
Two names, one number — m/m equals w/w — Industry writes weight by weight, science writes mass by mass, and since weight and mass are used interchangeably in ordinary practice the two figures are numerically equal.
Practice MCQs with answers (40)
- A solute dissolved in a given amount of solvent or solution
- B solvent used to dissolve a given amount of solute
- C residue left behind after the solution is filtered
- D heat needed to dissolve the solute completely
Show answer
Why:
It is what makes the proportion between the two precise.
- A 100 grams of the total solution
- B 100 grams of the solvent alone
- C 100 millilitres of the solution
- D one gram of the solvent
Show answer
Why:
The denominator is always the whole solution.
- A Mass by mass percentage
- B Volume by volume percentage
- C Mass by volume percentage
- D None of the three does
Show answer
Why:
Mass on top, volume underneath.
- A a solid has been dissolved in a liquid
- B a gas has been dissolved in a solid
- C two miscible liquids have been mixed together
- D nothing has actually been dissolved
Show answer
Why:
Perfumes, cosmetics and vinegar are the examples given.
- A Molarity
- B Percentage
- C Molality
- D Mole fraction
Show answer
Why:
The other methods are left for higher grades.
- A A spice mixture in a packet
- B A 5% glucose solution
- C A bottle of scent
- D A tin of milk powder
Show answer
Why:
Its solute is weighed but its solution is measured out.
- A Milk powder
- B A glucose drip
- C A spice mixture
- D Vinegar
Show answer
Why:
It is made from two liquids that mix into one another.
- A engineer
- B astronomer
- C paediatrician
- D botanist
Show answer
Why:
He formulated the rehydration solution the WHO went on to popularise.
- A Malaria and dengue
- B Diarrhoea and cholera
- C Tuberculosis and typhoid
- D Measles and mumps
Show answer
Why:
Both cause the body to lose fluid rapidly.
- A The first is always twice the second
- B They are equal to each other
- C The second is always twice the first
- D They can never be compared
Show answer
Why:
Weight and mass are used interchangeably in ordinary practice.
- A 11.1%
- B 10%
- C 9%
- D 90%
Show answer
Why:
The solution weighs 100 g in all, so the fraction is a tenth.
- A The answer should have been multiplied by 1000 instead of 100
- B The denominator should be the whole solution, which weighs 100 g
- C Salt cannot be expressed as a mass by mass percentage
- D Nothing went wrong; 11.1% is the correct answer
Show answer
Why:
Solute plus solvent gives the solution, and that is what goes below.
- A 4 g
- B 75 g
- C 12 g
- D 1.2 g
Show answer
Why:
Four grams in every hundred, scaled up three times.
- A 10%
- B 30%
- C 15%
- D 20%
Show answer
Why:
The concentrate comes to 30 mL in a total of 150 mL.
- A 5 mL of the acid and add 100 mL of water
- B 5 mL of the acid and add water to reach 100 mL
- C 95 mL of the acid and add water to reach 100 mL
- D 100 mL of the acid and add 5 mL of water
Show answer
Why:
The total volume of solution has to come out at 100 mL.
- A Masses cannot be measured accurately in a laboratory
- B Volumes are the only quantities medicines are sold by
- C Measuring out the volume of a liquid is easier there than weighing it
- D It always gives a larger number than the other methods
Show answer
Why:
The method is chosen to suit what is convenient to measure.
- A Pesticide loses its effect entirely above a certain amount
- B Extra pesticide simply evaporates without doing anything
- C It is not wrong; more always protects the crop better
- D Too much can damage the crops, the soil and the environment
Show answer
Why:
Too little leaves the crop unprotected, so the right proportion is wanted.
- A Water plays no part in the formulation at all
- B The proportion of salt and sugar to water is part of what makes it ORS
- C Only the amount of sugar has any effect on the result
- D Changing the water turns the solution heterogeneous
Show answer
Why:
The specified amounts go into a fixed amount of water.
- A Mass by mass percentage
- B Mass by volume percentage
- C Volume by volume percentage
- D None of the three applies to solids
Show answer
Why:
Packaged food labels use this method for salt, sugar and protein.
- A volume by volume percentage
- B mass by volume percentage
- C no percentage method at all
- D mass by mass percentage
Show answer
Why:
The method is not reserved for homogeneous mixtures.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Milk powder and spice mixtures are heterogeneous and still labelled this way.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Volume by volume measures both quantities as volumes.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Excess pesticide can damage the crops, the soil and the environment.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
That addition is the step most often skipped.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Measured salt is essential to it. The assertion holds, the reason is false.
- A 25%
- B 80%
- C 20%
- D 4%
Show answer
Why:
The solution weighs 100 g altogether.
- A 33.3%
- B 75%
- C 3%
- D 25%
Show answer
Why:
Solute plus solvent comes to 100 g.
- A 20 mL
- B 100 mL
- C 2 mL
- D 200 mL
Show answer
Why:
Ten millilitres in every hundred, so twenty needs twice that.
- A % v/v — the protein content of a food packet
- B % m/m — a glucose solution measured out in millilitres
- C % v/v — a perfume made from two liquids
- D % m/v — two miscible liquids mixed together
Show answer
Why:
Miscible liquids are measured by volume on both sides.
- A Any proportion works so long as the mixture is stirred well
- B The proportion only affects the appearance of the solution
- C Proportion matters in laboratories but nowhere else
- D Getting it wrong can make a preparation useless or actively harmful
Show answer
Why:
The pesticide and ORS cases both show this.
- A Medicine, agriculture, food, cosmetics and even making tea
- B Only in school and college laboratories
- C Only in medicine and nowhere else
- D Only in industries that package food
Show answer
Why:
It is an everyday idea as much as a laboratory one.
- A The total mass of the solution, being solute plus solvent
- B The volume the solution will occupy
- C The temperature at which it was prepared
- D The colour the solution has turned
Show answer
Why:
That total is what goes on the bottom of the fraction.
- A Weight by weight gives a more accurate figure
- B Mass cannot be measured on an industrial scale
- C The two express entirely different quantities
- D Weight and mass are generally used interchangeably in ordinary practice
Show answer
Why:
The two figures come out numerically equal.
- A 5 g
- B 10 g
- C 20 g
- D 100 g
Show answer
Why:
Five grams in every hundred millilitres, so twice that in two hundred.
- A The amount of the solvent
- B The amount of the whole solution
- C The amount of the solute
- D A different quantity in each case
Show answer
Why:
Only the units on it change from one method to the next.
- A Volume by volume percentages are impossible to measure
- B Pesticides work only at exactly one concentration
- C The rice crop absorbs all the water immediately
- D One millilitre in a hundred leaves little room for error either way
Show answer
Why:
Too little fails to protect and too much causes damage.
- A Both the glucose and the solution are weighed
- B Both the glucose and the solution are measured by volume
- C The glucose is weighed while the solution is made up to a volume
- D Neither quantity needs to be measured precisely
Show answer
Why:
That mixture of measurements is what makes it a mass by volume case.
- A Four grams of that substance in every hundred grams of the product
- B Four grams of that substance in every hundred millilitres
- C Four millilitres of that substance in every hundred grams
- D Four per cent of the product by volume
Show answer
Why:
Both quantities are masses in this method.
- A Weigh the concentrate and divide by the total volume
- B Divide the total volume by the volume of concentrate
- C Divide the volume of concentrate by the total volume and multiply by 100
- D Compare the colour with a chart
Show answer
Why:
Both quantities are volumes, so the method is volume by volume.
- A Tea is the only drink whose concentration can be measured
- B Tea has to be prepared in a laboratory to be accurate
- C Concentration has nothing to do with making tea
- D How much sugar or leaf goes into a fixed amount of water decides the result
Show answer
Why:
The chapter names it alongside medicine, agriculture and cosmetics.
Important short questions (8)
It is how much solute is carried by a stated quantity of solvent, or of the solution as a whole. It matters because the right proportion is essential when preparing a solution, whether in medicine, agriculture, food, cosmetics or even in making a cup of tea.
ORS is a measured thing: set weights of salt and sugar into a set volume of water. Alter the weights while keeping the water the same, or alter the water while keeping the weights, and what you end with is still salt and sugar dissolved in water, but it is no longer ORS. This is also why not all sugary drinks made at home or sold in shops count as ORS.
Too little pesticide may not protect the crops at all. Too much can damage the crops, the soil and the environment. So the right amount has to be mixed with a fixed amount of water, and more is not better.
$\text{% m/m} = \frac{\text{Mass of solute}}{\text{Mass of solution}} \times 100$. It reports the grams of solute carried in every 100 grams of finished solution. It is the figure quoted on packaged food, on milk powder and on spice mixes as much as on solutions.
The mass of solute is 10 g and the mass of solvent is 90 g, so the total mass of solution is $10 + 90 = 100$ g. The percentage is therefore $\frac{10\ \text{g}}{100\ \text{g}} \times 100 = 10%$ m/m.
Mass by volume percentage gives the grams of solute in 100 millilitres of solution. It is used where measuring a liquid's volume is easier than weighing it, as in a 5% glucose solution. Volume by volume percentage gives the millilitres of solute in 100 millilitres of solution and is used when two miscible liquids are mixed, as in vinegar, perfumes and cosmetics.
Four grams of zinc oxide are present in every 100 g of the powder, so in 300 g there are $\frac{4}{100} \times 300 = 12$ g of zinc oxide.
Vinegar contains 5% v/v acetic acid, and glacial acetic acid is the liquid at 100% strength. Since 5% v/v means 5 millilitres of solute in every 100 millilitres of solution, you would take 5 mL of glacial acetic acid and add enough water to bring the total volume of the solution to 100 mL.
Long answer questions (4)
Concentration is how much solute a stated quantity of solvent, or of the whole solution, carries. It is what turns a vague description into a precise one.
The first example is Oral Rehydration Solution. It takes set weights of salt and sugar into a set volume of water. Alter the weights while keeping the water the same, or alter the water while keeping the weights, and you still have salt and sugar dissolved in water, but you do not have ORS. The point is worth pressing, because a sweet drink mixed at home, or bought in a shop, is not thereby ORS.
The second is a pesticide spray. A farmer has the same problem: so much pesticide to so much water, and the proportion has to be right. Too little may not protect the crops, while too much can damage the crops, the soil and the environment, so the error runs both ways.
What both cases show is that getting the proportion right always matters when preparing a solution. The idea is not confined to laboratories either: it is at work in medicine, agriculture, food, cosmetics, and even while making a simple cup of tea.
Concentration can be expressed in several ways, and percentage is the one taken up at this level.
Mass by mass percentage is written $\text{% m/m} = \frac{\text{Mass of solute}}{\text{Mass of solution}} \times 100$, and it reports the grams of solute carried in every 100 grams of finished solution. It is used for homogeneous mixtures, but also for heterogeneous ones such as milk powder and spice mixtures, and for the labels on packaged foods that declare salt, sugar or protein.
Mass by volume percentage is written $\text{% m/v} = \frac{\text{Mass of solute}}{\text{Volume of solution}} \times 100$, and it gives the grams of solute in 100 millilitres of solution. It is the figure to reach for when a liquid is easier to measure out than to weigh, as in medicine and in the laboratory; the 5% glucose solution is the familiar case.
Volume by volume percentage is written $\text{% v/v} = \frac{\text{Volume of solute}}{\text{Volume of solution}} \times 100$, and it gives the millilitres of solute in 100 millilitres of solution. It is the method for two miscible liquids, as in perfumes, cosmetics and vinegar.
One point holds across all three: the quantity on the bottom is the whole solution, never the solvent alone.
The first concerns a mass by mass percentage. Salt weighing 10 g into 90 g of water gives 10 g of solute against 90 g of solvent, so the solution itself weighs $10 + 90 = 100$ g. The percentage is then $\frac{10\ \text{g}}{100\ \text{g}} \times 100 = 10%$ m/m.
The step that matters here is the addition. The denominator has to be the mass of the whole solution, and dividing by the 90 g of solvent instead would give the wrong answer.
The second concerns a mass by volume percentage. Glucose weighing 5 g made up with water to 100 mL gives 5 g of solute in 100 mL of solution, giving $\frac{5\ \text{g}}{100\ \text{mL}} \times 100 = 5%$ m/v. This is the familiar strength of a glucose solution.
The third concerns a volume by volume percentage. If 1 mL of a liquid pesticide is mixed with enough water to form 100 mL of spray for a rice crop, then $\frac{1\ \text{mL}}{100\ \text{mL}} \times 100 = 1%$ v/v.
In each case the method was chosen to match how the two quantities were measured.
The choice follows from how the two quantities have been measured. Weigh both the solute and the solution and the method is mass by mass. Weigh the solute but make the solution up to a volume and it is mass by volume. Measure both as volumes, which is what happens with two miscible liquids, and it is volume by volume.
For the talcum powder, 4% m/m means 4 g of zinc oxide in every 100 g of powder, so a 300 g tin holds $\frac{4}{100} \times 300 = 12$ g.
For the orange juice, two tablespoons at 15 mL each give $2 \times 15 = 30$ mL of concentrate, made up to 150 mL of juice. Since both quantities are volumes the method is volume by volume, giving $\frac{30}{150} \times 100 = 20%$ v/v.
For the vinegar, glacial acetic acid is the liquid at 100% strength and vinegar carries 5% v/v acetic acid. Since 5% v/v means 5 mL of solute in every 100 mL of solution, you would take 5 mL of glacial acetic acid and add water until the total volume reaches 100 mL.
One last point: industry commonly writes weight by weight percentage instead of mass by mass, since weight and mass are used interchangeably, and the two figures are numerically equal.
Flashcards (22)
Play this topic
- Concentration Methods Match
- True or False: Concentration
- Fill the Gaps: Concentration
- Unscramble: Concentration
Solubility and Crystallization
How much a solvent will hold depends on how warm it is, and that single fact can be turned into a separation technique. Cool a saturated solution and whatever it can no longer carry drops out as pure crystals, leaving the impurities behind in the liquid.
What you will be able to do
- Define solubility and a saturated solution, and say why temperature must be stated.
- Describe how the solubility of solids and of gases responds to a rise in temperature.
- Read a solubility curve and compare two solutes from it.
- Explain how cooling a saturated solution yields crystals, using figures from a curve.
- Set out the steps of the copper sulfate crystallization activity and the reason for each.
Key points
Solubility is the largest quantity of solute a fixed amount of solvent, taken as 100 mL or 100 g, will take up at a stated temperature.
Once a solution can take up no further solute at that temperature it is described as saturated.
The temperature has to be quoted because a solid solute in a liquid solvent will generally dissolve more freely as things warm up, while a gas dissolved in a liquid behaves the other way about and dissolves less.
Solubility is a valuable property precisely because it gives a handle on pulling substances back out of mixtures.
A saline drip in hospitals is ordinarily 0.9% m/v sodium chloride in water, which comes to 0.9 g of salt in every 100 mL of solution, a strength that is safe for blood and makes up fluid the body has lost.
Plotting solubility against temperature gives a solubility curve, with degrees Celsius along the horizontal axis and grams per 100 g of water up the vertical one.
For both compounds shown, less dissolves at 20 °C than at 60 °C, but the curve for B climbs the more steeply, so its solubility gains more from a rise in temperature than A's does.
Take 287 g of compound B dissolved in 100 g of water at 60 °C and cool it to 40 °C, where only 241 g can stay dissolved, and the surplus 46 g must leave the solution as a pure solid, commonly as crystals.
A crystal is a solid whose particles are set out in a regular geometric pattern.
Rock salt, the sugar crystals that grow while candy sugar or mishri is made, snowflakes formed as water vapour freezes in the air, and frost on a window pane are all crystals arising naturally.
Forming crystals from a saturated solution in the laboratory is called crystallization, and it separates two solids where one is present in small quantity and both dissolve in the same solvent.
It also purifies solids, and the principle behind that purification is simply that a substance does not dissolve equally well at every temperature.
Copper sulfate is toxic, so the activity is done under adult supervision and the solid is never handled with bare hands; the teacher adds the drop of dilute sulfuric acid, which is handled with great care.
That drop of acid helps produce pure crystals by heading off unwanted reactions, though it is needed only for certain salts.
Hot saturated solution is filtered to take out insoluble impurities, collected in a clean beaker and covered with a watch glass before being left to cool.
Cooling slowly and undisturbed gives the particles time enough to gather together, so the crystals come out larger, shinier, better shaped and a clear blue; cooling fast in ice-cold water gives smaller and poorer ones.
The crystals are finally filtered off, rinsed with cold water and left to dry on a watch glass.
Freshly prepared compounds usually arrive with unwanted impurities alongside them, and crystallization is the common way of drawing the wanted pure substance out of a homogeneous mixture.
Natural crystal deposits can be seen in mines, in caves such as the Mawsmai Cave at Sohra, also called Cherrapunji, and within the Earth's crust, with quartz among the most striking.
Full explanation
How Much Will Dissolve?
There is a limit to what a solvent will take. Keep adding solute to a set quantity of solvent — 100 mL of it, or 100 g — and there comes a point where no more will go in. That limit, at the temperature you are working at, is the solubility.
Once it will accept nothing further at that temperature, the solution is saturated.
Why mention temperature every time?
Because the figure moves with it, and in opposite directions for solids and gases:
| Solute | As temperature rises |
|---|---|
| A solid in a liquid | Solubility generally increases |
| A gas in a liquid | Solubility generally decreases |
Solids up, gases down.
Solubility is an important property we use to separate substances from mixtures, which is exactly what the rest of this topic is about.
Threads of Curiosity: The Saline Drip
The saline a hospital runs into a vein is normally 0.9% m/v sodium chloride — ordinary salt — which is to say 0.9 g of it in every 100 mL.
That particular strength is safe for blood and replaces fluids the body has lost.
Activity 5.2: The Solubility Curve
Take water as the solvent and two compounds, A and B, as solutes. Each has a different solubility.
A graph of solubility against temperature is called a solubility curve:
- the x-axis shows temperature in °C,
- the y-axis shows solubility in grams per 100 g of water.
From the curves, fill these in:
- The solubility of A at 20 °C is ______ its solubility at 60 °C.
- The solubility of B at 20 °C is ______ its solubility at 60 °C.
- The solubility of ______ increases more than that of ______ with a rise in temperature.
For the first two the answer is less than: both dissolve more freely when warmer. For the third, B gains more than A, since its curve climbs the more steeply.
Which raises the question the next section answers: what happens if you prepare a saturated solution at a higher temperature and then cool it slowly?
What Cooling Does
Take a saturated solution of compound B at 60 °C, made by dissolving 287 g of it in 100 g of water. Now cool it gradually to 40 °C.
From the curve, the solubility of B at 40 °C is 241 g per 100 g of water.
So only 241 g can remain in the solution. The rest — the surplus 46 g — has nowhere to go. What comes out is solid and pure, and commonly crystalline.
A crystal is a solid whose particles are stacked in a repeating, orderly arrangement.
Crystals Around You
You have very likely seen crystals already:
- rock salt crystals,
- sugar crystals that grow as candy sugar is made, called mishri in Hindi,
- snowflakes, formed when water vapour freezes in the air,
- frost on windows, formed when water vapour turns into ice crystals.
That is how crystals form naturally.
Crystallization
Growing crystals out of a saturated solution is what a laboratory calls crystallization.
It does two jobs:
- Separation. Two solids can be parted this way when one of them is only a minor component and the same solvent takes up both.
- Purification. It can purify solids. The whole method turns on one fact: a substance does not dissolve equally well hot and cold.
Activity 5.3: Growing Copper Sulfate Crystals
Collect a sample of copper sulfate (blue vitriol). Failing that, ordinary salt will do instead.
Safety first: copper sulfate is poisonous. Have an adult present throughout, and keep it off your skin.
The steps
-
Take 1 g of copper sulfate in a 100 mL beaker. Add 25 mL of water and a drop of dilute sulfuric acid. Heat gently in a water bath, stirring constantly.
That drop of acid holds off side reactions, so what grows is clean.
Safety first: leave the acid to the teacher. Handle it very carefully.
-
Gradually add more copper sulfate until the solution becomes saturated.
-
Filter the hot solution to remove insoluble impurities. Collect the filtrate in a clean beaker and lay over it a watch glass.
-
Allow it to cool slowly, without disturbing it. This gives the particles in the solution enough time to come together, so that the crystals come out larger, shiny, well-shaped and blue.
-
Filter the crystals, rinse them with cold water, and let them dry on a watch glass.
Note: only certain salts call for acid at this step.
Why each step is there
| Step | Reason |
|---|---|
| Add acid | Prevents unwanted reactions, so the crystals come out pure |
| Filter hot | Removes insoluble impurities before anything crystallises |
| Cover and cool slowly | Gives particles time to gather into large, well-formed crystals |
| Rinse with cold water | Cleans the crystals without dissolving them again |
Think as a Scientist
Plunge the hot saturated solution into iced water and what grows is small and poorly shaped beside what grows when it is left to cool slowly on the bench.
How would you design an experiment to test that?
Hint: Prepare a hot saturated solution and divide it into two equal parts.
Why This Matters
Getting a pure substance back out of a uniform mixture is routinely done this way.
A freshly made compound rarely comes clean; something unwanted comes with it. Crystallization is how the two are parted.
Pause and Ponder
- Looking again at the solubility curves: if equal masses of hot saturated solutions of A and B are cooled from 80 °C to 60 °C, which is likely to deposit more solid?
- Does the size of the common salt crystals depend on how fast the water is driven off? Give your reasoning.
Activity 5.4 and Crystals in Nature
Salt crystals are obtained from seawater: the water is concentrated into a saturated solution, and the salt crystals then separate out.
And crystals occur on a far larger scale without any help. Big deposits are found in mines, in caves — the Mawsmai Cave at Sohra (Cherrapunji) is one such place — and within the Earth's crust. Quartz is among the most beautiful of them.
Concepts and terms
The largest quantity of a solute that a fixed amount of solvent, taken as 100 mL or 100 g, will dissolve at a stated temperature. The temperature must be given, since the figure changes with it.
A solution that will take up no further solute at that temperature. Adding more simply leaves it undissolved.
A graph of solubility against temperature, with degrees Celsius along the horizontal axis and grams of solute per 100 g of water up the vertical one. Comparing two curves compares two solutes at a glance.
A solid whose particles are arranged in a regular geometric pattern. Rock salt, candy sugar, snowflakes and window frost are all examples.
The laboratory process of forming crystals from a saturated solution. It separates two solids dissolved in the same solvent where one is present in small quantity, and it purifies solids.
Did you know
Snowflakes are crystals, formed when water vapour freezes in the air, and the frost on a window pane forms the same way.
The Mawsmai Cave at Sohra, better known as Cherrapunji, is one of the places where natural crystal formations can be seen.
A hospital saline drip is usually 0.9% m/v sodium chloride, a strength chosen because it is safe for blood.
Memory tricks
Which way solubility moves — Solids up, gases down — Warm the liquid and a solid solute dissolves more freely, while a dissolved gas does the opposite and escapes more readily.
Why crystals appear on cooling — The solution cannot hold what it once could — At 60 °C compound B can carry 287 g, at 40 °C only 241 g. The 46 g difference has nowhere to go but out.
Getting good crystals — Slow and undisturbed — Slow cooling gives the particles time to gather, yielding larger, shinier, better-shaped crystals than a rapid chill does.
Practice MCQs with answers (40)
- A any quantity of solvent whatever the temperature
- B a fixed quantity of solute at a stated temperature
- C a solution that is already saturated
- D a fixed quantity of solvent at a stated temperature
Show answer
Why:
The fixed quantity is taken as 100 mL or 100 g.
- A concentrated, which only means it carries a good deal of solute
- B homogeneous, which describes any mixture that is uniform throughout
- C heterogeneous, which describes a mixture whose parts can be told apart
- D saturated, since anything further added simply stays undissolved
Show answer
Why:
Anything added beyond that point stays undissolved.
- A decreases, so less of it dissolves
- B increases, so more of it dissolves
- C stays exactly the same throughout
- D falls to zero at once
Show answer
Why:
A gas dissolved in a liquid does the opposite.
- A decreases, so less of it stays dissolved
- B increases, so more of it dissolves
- C stays exactly the same throughout
- D doubles for every ten degrees
Show answer
Why:
This is why the two families are said to move opposite ways.
- A saturation line
- B cooling curve
- C purity graph
- D solubility curve
Show answer
Why:
Grams per 100 g of water go up the vertical axis.
- A arranged in a regular geometric pattern
- B scattered without any order at all
- C constantly changing their positions
- D all of one single size and colour
Show answer
Why:
That internal order is what gives the outward shape.
- A filtration, which holds back whatever never dissolved at all
- B crystallization, which both separates and purifies solids
- C evaporation, which drives the solvent off as a vapour
- D saturation, which is reaching the limit of what will dissolve
Show answer
Why:
It both separates and purifies solids.
- A 0.9% m/v
- B 9% m/v
- C 0.09% m/v
- D 90% m/v
Show answer
Why:
That works out to 0.9 g of the salt in every 100 mL of liquid.
- A A snowflake in the air
- B Frost on a window pane
- C A grain of rock salt
- D A drop of liquid water
Show answer
Why:
The other three all have particles in a regular pattern.
- A rock salt
- B blue vitriol
- C quartz
- D glacial acid
Show answer
Why:
Common salt may be used in its place in the activity.
- A Temperature is the unit solubility is measured in
- B Solubility only exists above room temperature
- C The figure changes as the temperature changes
- D It is a convention with no reason behind it
Show answer
Why:
Solids and gases even change in opposite directions.
- A 241 g of pure solid separating out
- B 287 g of pure solid separating out
- C 46 g of pure solid separating out
- D no solid at all
Show answer
Why:
Only what the cooler solution cannot carry has to leave it.
- A It dissolves less at every temperature shown
- B It cannot form a saturated solution at all
- C Its solubility falls as the temperature rises
- D Its solubility gains more from a rise in temperature
Show answer
Why:
Which is why it deposits more solid when cooled.
- A To make the solution cool down more quickly
- B To break up the crystals that have already appeared
- C To add the sulfuric acid more evenly
- D To take out insoluble impurities before any crystals form
Show answer
Why:
Filtering afterwards would gather the impurities with the crystals.
- A It prevents the solution from evaporating entirely
- B It keeps the sulfuric acid from reacting further
- C It allows the impurities to settle to the bottom
- D It gives the particles time to come together into larger crystals
Show answer
Why:
Rapid chilling gives smaller and less well-formed crystals.
- A It raises the solubility of copper sulfate sharply
- B It helps give pure crystals by preventing unwanted reactions
- C It provides the blue colour of the crystals
- D It is needed for the crystallization of every salt
Show answer
Why:
It is required for only some salts, not all.
- A The colour of the crystals that are formed
- B The size of the beaker being used
- C The impurities being heavier than the solute
- D The solubility of a substance differing at different temperatures
Show answer
Why:
What the cooled solution cannot hold leaves it, while impurities stay dissolved.
- A one is present in small quantity and both dissolve in the same solvent
- B both are present in equal quantity and neither dissolves
- C one is a gas and the other a liquid at room temperature
- D they have exactly the same solubility at every temperature
Show answer
Why:
Equal solubility at all temperatures would defeat the method.
- A Warm water would change their colour
- B Cold water makes them grow larger still
- C Cold water cleans them without dissolving them again
- D Warm water is not available in the laboratory
Show answer
Why:
A solid dissolves more freely in warm water than in cold.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Statements 1 and 2 are exactly why 3 cannot hold.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
It is a technique for separating pure substances from homogeneous mixtures.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The filtrate is cooled slowly and undisturbed, not chilled.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Solubility shifts with temperature, which is why the figure needs one attached. The assertion is sound, the reason false.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
A rapid chill leaves smaller and less well-formed crystals.
- A A, because its curve is the gentler of the two
- B B, because its solubility falls more sharply over that range
- C Both deposit exactly the same amount
- D Neither deposits anything at all
Show answer
Why:
The steeper curve means a bigger drop in what can stay dissolved.
- A unsaturated at that temperature
- B saturated at that temperature
- C no longer a solution at all
- D heterogeneous by definition
Show answer
Why:
Any further addition would simply sit undissolved.
- A Solubility is the only property any substance possesses
- B Mixtures cannot be separated by any other means
- C Changing the temperature changes what a solution can hold, forcing solid out
- D It makes every mixture homogeneous on heating
Show answer
Why:
That is exactly the mechanism crystallization uses.
- A A filter paper
- B A glass rod
- C A watch glass
- D A tripod stand
Show answer
Why:
The same piece is later used to dry the crystals on.
- A 25 mL
- B 100 mL
- C 50 mL
- D 5 mL
Show answer
Why:
The beaker used holds 100 mL.
- A A flame cannot reach the temperature required
- B Water baths are the only equipment available
- C It gives gentle and even heating while the mixture is stirred
- D It makes the sulfuric acid evaporate faster
Show answer
Why:
The step is described as gentle heating with constant stirring.
- A New compounds cannot be weighed until they are crystallised
- B Crystals are the only form a compound can be stored in
- C Newly made compounds usually carry unwanted impurities that must be removed
- D It converts the compound into a different substance
Show answer
Why:
It draws the desired pure substance out of the mixture.
- A They crystallise first and are collected separately
- B They evaporate away during the heating step
- C They stay behind in the solution while the pure solid crystallises out
- D They combine with the solute to form new crystals
Show answer
Why:
Only the substance whose solubility has been exceeded leaves the solution.
- A Cool slowly, saturate, filter hot, filter the crystals
- B Filter hot, saturate, filter the crystals, cool slowly
- C Filter the crystals, cool slowly, saturate, filter hot
- D Saturate, filter hot, cool slowly, filter the crystals
Show answer
Why:
Filtering hot has to come before anything crystallises.
- A Solubility is never measured in grams
- B The curve cannot be read at a single point
- C Nothing is wrong; temperature is irrelevant here
- D The figure means nothing without the temperature it applies to
Show answer
Why:
The same compound carries 287 g at a higher temperature.
- A Deep inside a salt mine in Rajasthan
- B At Sohra, also called Cherrapunji
- C On the floor of the Arabian Sea
- D In a laboratory in New Delhi
Show answer
Why:
Quartz is named alongside as a naturally occurring crystal.
- A Filtering seawater to collect salt on the filter paper
- B Concentrating seawater to a saturated solution so salt crystals separate
- C Cooling seawater until it freezes into salt
- D Adding acid to seawater to precipitate the salt
Show answer
Why:
It is the same principle the laboratory activity applies.
- A Make two solutions of different substances and compare them
- B Make one hot saturated solution and divide it into two equal parts
- C Cool the same solution twice on different days
- D Compare crystals bought from two different shops
Show answer
Why:
Dividing one solution keeps everything but the cooling rate the same.
- A It holds 0.9 g of sodium chloride in every 100 mL of solution
- B It holds 0.9 g of sodium chloride in every 100 g of solution
- C It holds 9 g of sodium chloride in every 100 mL of solution
- D It holds 0.9 mL of sodium chloride in every 100 mL of solution
Show answer
Why:
The m/v notation puts a mass over a volume.
- A It dissolves faster than any other substance
- B It produces blue crystals just as copper sulfate does
- C It crystallises in the same way while being safe to handle
- D It removes the need for any heating at all
Show answer
Why:
Copper sulfate is toxic and must not be touched with bare hands.
- A They are smaller and irregular in form
- B They are larger, shiny and well shaped
- C They dissolve again immediately in cold water
- D They lose their colour on drying
Show answer
Why:
Rapid chilling gives the opposite result.
Important short questions (8)
Solubility is the largest quantity of solute that a fixed amount of solvent, taken as 100 mL or 100 g, will dissolve at a stated temperature. A saturated solution is one that will take up no further solute at that temperature, so anything added beyond that point stays undissolved.
Because the figure shifts as the temperature shifts. For a solid solute in a liquid solvent the solubility generally increases as things warm up, while for a gas dissolved in a liquid it generally decreases. Without a temperature the number does not say anything definite.
It is a graph of solubility against temperature, with degrees Celsius along the horizontal axis and grams of solute per 100 g of water up the vertical one. Of two curves on the same axes, the steeper one belongs to the solute whose solubility gains more from a rise in temperature.
Only 241 g can stay dissolved at the lower temperature, so the surplus of $287 - 241 = 46$ g must leave the solution. It separates out as a pure solid, commonly in the form of crystals.
A crystal is a solid whose particles are arranged in a regular geometric pattern. Rock salt, snowflakes formed when water vapour freezes in the air, and frost on window panes are three that occur without any laboratory involved.
It is the laboratory process of forming crystals from a saturated solution. It can separate two solids where one is present in small quantity and both dissolve in the same solvent, and it can also purify solids.
Filtering while hot removes insoluble impurities before any crystals have formed, so they are not collected along with the product. Cooling slowly and without disturbance gives the particles in the solution enough time to come together, which yields larger, shiny, well-shaped crystals rather than the small poorly formed ones a rapid chill produces.
It turns on one fact: a substance does not dissolve equally well hot and cold. On cooling, the solution can no longer hold as much of the wanted substance, so the excess separates out as pure solid. The impurities, being present in far smaller quantity, have not exceeded their own solubility and so stay dissolved in the liquid.
Long answer questions (4)
Solubility is the point at which a set quantity of solvent — 100 mL or 100 g — will take no more solute, at whatever temperature you are working at. Once a solution cannot dissolve any more solute at that temperature it is described as saturated.
The temperature has to be quoted every time, and the reason is that the figure moves with it.
For a solid solute in a liquid solvent, the solubility generally increases as the temperature rises. More of the solid will go into the same amount of liquid simply because the liquid is warmer.
For a gas dissolved in a liquid, the behaviour runs the other way. Solubility generally decreases as the temperature rises, so a warm liquid holds less dissolved gas than a cold one.
Because of this, a solubility figure quoted without a temperature says nothing definite. The same compound may carry 287 g in 100 g of water at one temperature and only 241 g at another.
Solubility matters beyond definitions because it is an important property used to separate substances from mixtures. Changing the temperature changes what a solution is able to hold, and whatever it can no longer hold has to leave it.
A solubility curve is a graph of solubility against temperature, with degrees Celsius along the horizontal axis and grams of solute per 100 g of water up the vertical one. Reading two values off it is enough to predict what cooling will do.
Take a saturated solution of compound B at 60 °C, made by dissolving 287 g of it in 100 g of water. Now cool it gradually to 40 °C.
At 40 °C the curve gives the solubility of B as 241 g per 100 g of water. That is all the solution is able to hold at the lower temperature.
It follows that only 241 g can remain in the solution, and the rest of it, which is 46 g, has nowhere to stay. It separates out as a pure solid, often in the form of crystals, a crystal being a solid whose particles are arranged in a regular geometric pattern.
The same reasoning explains a related result. If equal masses of hot saturated solutions of two compounds are cooled over the same range, the one whose curve is steeper will deposit more solid, because its solubility has fallen further over that range.
Two safety points come first. Copper sulfate is toxic, so the experiment is performed under adult supervision and it is not touched with bare hands. The drop of dilute sulfuric acid should be added by the teacher, and the acid is handled very carefully. Common salt may be used instead where copper sulfate is unavailable.
Take 1 g of copper sulfate in a 100 mL beaker, add 25 mL of water and a drop of dilute sulfuric acid, and heat the mixture gently in a water bath while stirring constantly. The acid helps in making pure crystals by preventing unwanted reactions, though it is required for only some salts.
Gradually add more copper sulfate until the solution becomes saturated.
Filter the hot solution to remove insoluble impurities, collect the filtrate in a clean beaker, and lay over it a watch glass. Filtering at this stage matters, because doing it later would gather the impurities in with the crystals.
Allow the solution to cool slowly without disturbing it. This gives the particles in the solution enough time to come together, so that larger, shiny, well-shaped and blue crystals result. Chilling it rapidly in ice-cold water would give smaller and less well-formed ones instead.
Last, put them through a filter, wash them down with cold water and leave them on a watch glass to dry.
Crystallization is a common technique for separating pure substances, in the form of crystals, from homogeneous mixtures. It does two jobs. Two solids can be parted this way when one is only a minor component and the same solvent takes up both; and it will clean up a solid besides.
The reason it works is stated simply enough: purification by this route works because a substance does not dissolve equally well at every temperature. On cooling, the solution can no longer hold as much of the wanted substance, so the surplus leaves it as pure solid, while the impurities, present in far smaller quantity, have not reached their own limit and stay dissolved.
This is why the method matters in practice. A freshly made compound rarely comes clean, and crystallization is how what is wanted is parted from what is not.
The same process happens without any apparatus at all. Rock salt crystals, the sugar crystals that grow while candy sugar or mishri is made, snowflakes formed when water vapour freezes in the air, and frost on windows are all crystals formed naturally.
On a larger scale still, crystal deposits occur in mines, in caves such as the Mawsmai Cave at Sohra or Cherrapunji, and within the Earth's crust, quartz being one of the most beautiful.
Flashcards (22)
Play this topic
- Solubility and Crystals Match
- True or False: Solubility and Crystals
- Fill the Gaps: Solubility
- Unscramble: Crystals
Distillation and Paper Chromatography
Evaporation recovers the solid but throws the liquid away. Distillation keeps both, by boiling off the lower-boiling liquid and catching its vapour again, while paper chromatography pulls a mixture apart by letting a solvent carry its parts up a strip at different speeds.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how distillation separates two miscible liquids and what the difference in boiling point must be.
- Describe the distillation apparatus and the part each piece plays.
- Distinguish simple distillation from fractional distillation.
- Set out the steps of the paper chromatography activity, including where the solvent level must sit.
- Explain what paper chromatography separates on, and name applications of both techniques.
Key points
Letting a solvent evaporate does recover the solute, salt from a salt solution for instance, but the solvent itself is lost, so a method is needed that keeps both.
Two liquids that mix into one another, such as acetone and water accidentally poured together, cannot be told apart by evaporation alone either.
A homogeneous mixture of two miscible liquids is separated by warming it until the liquid of lower boiling point turns to vapour, then chilling that vapour so it returns to liquid, and the whole procedure is called distillation.
It lets the solvent be recovered, and it separates liquids whose boiling points stand at least about 25 °C apart; it also draws a liquid out of a solution holding dissolved solids.
The vapour of the lower-boiling liquid travels into a condenser, is chilled there by circulating water or air, and returns as a pure liquid collected in a separate vessel.
Whatever else was in the mixture, whether a solid or the second liquid, stays behind in the distillation flask.
The apparatus carries a thermometer, a distillation flask on wire gauze above a burner, a water condenser with its own inlet and outlet, and a conical flask to receive what comes over.
Acetone boils at about 56 °C and water at 100 °C, and a gap that wide lets one liquid turn to vapour before the other produces vapour in any significant amount.
Fractional distillation handles mixtures whose boiling points lie closer together, differing by less than 25 °C, and it is how crude petroleum is split into its useful fractions.
A petroleum refinery processes crude oil taken from the Earth's crust into petroleum gas, petrol, kerosene, diesel and more, with the gaseous fraction compressed into steel cylinders where it liquefies and is sold as LPG for domestic use.
Distillation has long served to draw fragrances out of flowers, and at Kannauj in Uttar Pradesh, the perfume capital of India, the earthy scent that rises after the first rain is captured as Mitti ka Ittar by the traditional Deg-Bhapka method.
The Fragrance and Flavour Development Centre there separates flavour and fragrance components from flowers, leaves and other plant parts, helps farmers grow fragrance-producing plants, and advises those setting up perfume businesses.
Salt crystallization is an old craft of India's coastal communities, with panga salt obtained by boiling concentrated sea brines and karkatch salt by letting seawater evaporate, each giving crystals of different sizes.
Drop water onto something written with a sketch pen and the colour spreads, and where the pen was black several colours may spread out separately.
In the activity a pencil line is drawn 2 cm from the bottom of a 3 cm strip of chromatographic paper, an ink spot is marked at its centre, and the strip is stood in a thin layer of water so that the water level sits below the spot.
As the liquid climbs the paper, the ink begins to part into separate coloured spots, and this way of separating a mixture is called paper chromatography.
It works on differences in how the components interact with the solvent and with the paper, the liquid carrying each substance upward and sorting them by how quickly they travel.
The same thing can be done with green food colour using a 2% m/v salt solution, or on the pigments in a green extract of spinach leaves or in flower petals, though water is not always a suitable solvent and alcohol or a blend of solvents may be needed.
The word chromatography comes from the Greek chroma, colour, and graphein, to write, so it means writing with colour, the technique having first been applied to coloured substances such as dyes and inks.
Full explanation
The Problem Evaporation Leaves Behind
Let a solvent evaporate and you get the solute back — salt from a salt solution, for instance. But the solvent disappears.
What if you want to recover the solvent too?
And there is a harder case. Suppose a student accidentally mixes acetone and water, two miscible liquids. Evaporation is no help at all here: is it even possible to separate two miscible liquids and obtain both?
Distillation
It is, and the method has a name.
Two liquids that mix freely can be parted by warming them until whichever boils lower goes off as vapour, and then chilling that vapour back to liquid. This process is known as distillation.
What it can do:
- recover the solvent,
- separate liquids whose boiling points differ by at least about 25 °C,
- separate a liquid from a solution containing dissolved solids.
How the apparatus works
The vapour of the lower-boiling one is led through a condenser, chilled there by water or air kept moving around it, and runs off clean.
That pure liquid, the distillate, is collected in a separate vessel. The solid or the other liquid from the mixture remains in the distillation flask.
| Part | What it does |
|---|---|
| Distillation flask | Holds the mixture; sits on wire gauze over the burner |
| Thermometer | Reads the temperature of the vapour leaving the flask |
| Water condenser | Chills the vapour back to liquid, with its own water inlet and outlet |
| Conical flask | Receives the pure distillate |
Why acetone and water work
Acetone and water come apart under distillation because the gap between their boiling points is wide enough:
- acetone goes off at around 56 °C,
- water boils at 100 °C.
A large difference lets one liquid vaporise before the vapours of the other are formed in significant amount. If the two boiled at the same temperature, distillation would achieve nothing.
Fractional Distillation
What if the boiling points are closer together than 25 °C?
Where the boiling points sit close together — under 25 °C apart — the method needed is fractional distillation.
This is the industrial workhorse. A petroleum refinery is an industrial unit where crude oil is processed into various useful products.
Crude petroleum is extracted from the Earth's crust and separated by fractional distillation into fractions including:
- petroleum gas
- petrol
- aviation fuel (kerosene)
- diesel
- lubricating oil
- bitumen
The gaseous fraction is filled into steel cylinders under high pressure, where it liquefies. That is Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG), used as domestic fuel.
India's Scientific Contributions
Salt from the coast
Along the Indian coast, salt has been won this way since antiquity by the people living there.
- Panga salt was obtained by boiling concentrated sea brines.
- Karkatch salt came from the evaporation of seawater.
Salt crystals of different sizes were produced by these methods.
Perfume from Kannauj
Scent has been drawn out of flowers by distillation for a very long time.
Everyone knows the smell the ground gives up when the first rain lands on it. At Kannauj in Uttar Pradesh — the town India makes its perfume in — that smell is caught and bottled as Mitti ka Ittar.
The still used is the old Deg-Bhapka, handed down in Kannauj from one generation of perfumers to the next, and what it produces sells at home and abroad.
Kannauj also has the Fragrance and Flavour Development Centre, equipped to draw scent and flavour out of flowers, leaves and the rest of a plant. It helps growers raise the crops these come from, and advises anyone setting up in the trade.
Paper Chromatography
Let a drop of water land on sketch-pen writing and watch: the colour runs. And if the pen was black, different colours might spread out separately.
That observation is a whole separation technique in miniature.
Activity 5.5
- Cut a strip of chromatographic paper 3 cm across, and rule a pencil line across it, 2 cm up from one end. A strip of filter paper will serve as an alternative.
- Put a single dot of black sketch pen on the middle of that line.
- Put enough water in a gas jar, measuring cylinder or beaker to make a thin layer at the bottom.
- Set the strip upright with its foot in the water, taking care that the water sits below the dot and does not reach it.
- Observe the paper as the water rises through it.
- As the water climbs the paper, the ink opens out into separate patches of colour.
What follows from that? That the black dot was never a single substance.
What Makes It Work
Parting a mixture in this fashion is called paper chromatography. It works because each component clings to the paper, and travels with the liquid, to a different degree. The liquid draws them all upward, and they sort themselves out by how quickly each is carried.
So two things matter for each component: how it gets on with the solvent, and how it gets on with the paper. A component held more tightly by the paper lags behind; one carried readily by the solvent races ahead.
Other things to try
- Green food colour instead of black ink, using a 2% m/v salt solution as the solvent.
- The pigments in a green extract of spinach leaves.
- Coloured pigments from flower petals.
Does water serve as a solvent in every case? No. In some cases you may need another solvent, such as alcohol, or a mixture of solvents.
Threads of Curiosity: The Name
The word chromatography comes from the Greek chroma, meaning colour, and graphein, meaning to write. It literally means writing with colour, because it was first used to separate coloured substances such as dyes and inks.
Pause and Ponder
True or false? Correct the false ones.
| Statement | Verdict |
|---|---|
| Salt will come back out of brine by driving off the water, or by distilling it | True |
| Distillation can separate two liquids even when they have the same boiling point | False — the boiling points must differ by at least about 25 °C |
| The solvent level must stay above the sample spot at the start | False — it must be below the spot |
| Evaporation and crystallization are the same process | False — crystallization forms crystals from a saturated solution and gives a pure, well-shaped solid |
Concepts and terms
Warming a mixture until the liquid of lower boiling point turns to vapour, then chilling that vapour back to liquid. It recovers the solvent as well as the solute, which evaporation cannot do.
The part of the apparatus where the vapour is chilled, usually by circulating water or air, so that it returns as a pure liquid and can be collected separately.
Simple distillation works where the two liquids' boiling points stand at least about 25 °C apart. A gap that wide lets one vaporise before the other produces much vapour.
The method for mixtures whose boiling points differ by less than 25 °C. Crude petroleum is split this way into petroleum gas, petrol, kerosene, diesel and the rest.
Separating a mixture by letting a solvent climb a paper strip, carrying the components with it at different speeds according to how each interacts with the solvent and the paper.
Did you know
Chromatography takes its name from the Greek chroma, colour, and graphein, to write, because it was first used on coloured substances such as dyes and inks.
Kannauj in Uttar Pradesh is known as the perfume capital of India, and the scent of the first rain on dry earth is bottled there as Mitti ka Ittar.
The gaseous fraction from crude oil is squeezed into steel cylinders under high pressure until it liquefies, which is how LPG reaches a kitchen.
Memory tricks
Why distillation beats evaporation — Evaporation keeps one, distillation keeps both — Letting a solvent evaporate leaves the solute but loses the solvent. Distillation catches the vapour and returns it as pure liquid, so nothing is thrown away.
Choosing the method — Far apart simple, close together fractional — Boiling points at least 25 °C apart allow simple distillation. Closer than that and fractional distillation is needed.
Setting up the chromatography strip — Solvent below the spot, never above — If the water level rises above the ink mark, the ink washes off into the liquid instead of climbing the paper.
Practice MCQs with answers (40)
- A filtering the mixture through a fine paper
- B letting the whole mixture evaporate into the air
- C heating until the lower-boiling one vaporises, then cooling that vapour
- D adding a solid that dissolves one of them
Show answer
Why:
Both liquids are recovered, unlike in evaporation.
- A 5 °C, a gap that almost any two liquids would provide
- B 100 °C, the temperature at which water boils in the open
- C 1 °C, so that very nearly any mixture could be separated
- D 25 °C, below which fractional distillation is needed instead
Show answer
Why:
Closer than that and fractional distillation is needed.
- A In the distillation flask
- B In the thermometer
- C On the wire gauze
- D In the condenser
Show answer
Why:
Circulating water or air does the cooling.
- A 100 °C, the same temperature at which water boils
- B 25 °C, which is around ordinary room temperature
- C 56 °C, well below the temperature at which water boils
- D 156 °C, which is well above the boiling point of water
Show answer
Why:
Water boils at 100 °C, a comfortable gap away.
- A more than 100 °C
- B less than 25 °C
- C exactly 25 °C
- D no amount at all
Show answer
Why:
Simple distillation handles the wider gaps.
- A the surface of the sea
- B the upper atmosphere
- C plant material
- D the Earth's crust
Show answer
Why:
A refinery then splits it into fractions.
- A at low pressure, where it expands
- B after cooling it with liquid nitrogen
- C after mixing it with kerosene
- D under high pressure, where it liquefies
Show answer
Why:
It is then used as domestic fuel.
- A Sohra, better known by the name Cherrapunji
- B Kannauj, which lies in the state of Uttar Pradesh
- C Jaipur, in the desert state of Rajasthan
- D Mysuru, in the southern state of Karnataka
Show answer
Why:
It lies in Uttar Pradesh.
- A a black sketch pen, the same one used for the spot
- B a pencil, whose marks the solvent cannot carry upward
- C a blue ballpoint pen, drawn against a ruler
- D a brush and paint, applied in a thin line
Show answer
Why:
Ink would itself be carried up by the solvent.
- A separating by weight, from an older Latin root
- B measuring with paper, after the strips it uses
- C writing with colour, from the Greek chroma and graphein
- D boiling with water, after the solvent it needs
Show answer
Why:
From the Greek chroma and graphein.
- A Acetone is heavier than water and sinks to the bottom
- B The two liquids do not actually mix together
- C Acetone dissolves in water only when it is warm
- D Their boiling points stand far enough apart for one to vaporise first
Show answer
Why:
About 56 °C against 100 °C is a comfortable gap.
- A Both are separated perfectly and collected in turn
- B The mixture turns heterogeneous on heating
- C The method fails, since neither vaporises appreciably before the other
- D Only the heavier of the two comes over
Show answer
Why:
A difference of at least about 25 °C is required.
- A Otherwise the paper strip floats out of the container
- B Otherwise the ink dissolves into the liquid instead of climbing the paper
- C Otherwise the water cannot rise through the paper at all
- D Otherwise the pencil line is washed away first
Show answer
Why:
The solvent has to reach the spot by travelling up the paper.
- A How each interacts with the solvent and with the paper
- B How heavy each component is
- C What colour each component appears to be
- D How hot each component has to be made
Show answer
Why:
Those two interactions decide how fast each one travels.
- A race ahead of the others up the strip
- B remain exactly at the baseline for ever
- C dissolve completely into the solvent
- D lag behind the others as the solvent rises
Show answer
Why:
One carried readily by the solvent moves fastest.
- A They are different processes, crystallization giving a pure well-shaped solid
- B They are the same process under two different names
- C Evaporation always gives larger crystals than crystallization
- D Crystallization removes the solvent without any cooling
Show answer
Why:
Crystallization forms crystals from a saturated solution.
- A It stays behind in the distillation flask
- B It passes through the condenser with the vapour
- C It collects in the conical flask as distillate
- D It escapes through the water outlet
Show answer
Why:
Only the lower-boiling liquid comes over.
- A Paper chromatography
- B Fractional distillation
- C Crystallization
- D Simple filtration
Show answer
Why:
The fractions' boiling points lie close together.
- A Acetone
- B Diesel
- C Bitumen
- D Lubricating oil
Show answer
Why:
Petroleum gas, petrol and kerosene are others.
- A 1 and 3 only
- B 1 and 2 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Equal boiling points defeat the method entirely.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The strip is placed vertically, with its lower end dipping in.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Salt crystals of different sizes were produced by these methods.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Both are true, but the boiling-point condition is not what makes distillation the better choice when the solvent is wanted back.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Their interactions with solvent and paper differ.
- A Pure glacial acetic acid
- B A 50% sugar solution
- C A 2% m/v salt solution
- D Boiling water only
Show answer
Why:
Water alone is not suitable for every separation.
- A Water cannot rise through paper at all
- B Alcohol makes the paper strip stronger
- C Some components interact too little with water to be carried up
- D Water dissolves the pencil line away
Show answer
Why:
The solvent has to suit the mixture being separated.
- A Dry wood and tree bark
- B Rice grains and wheat flour
- C Coconut shell and peanut skin
- D A green extract of spinach leaves, and flower petals
Show answer
Why:
Both carry coloured pigments to be separated.
- A The separated spots are always written down in colour
- B Its earliest use was on coloured things such as dyes and inks
- C The paper has to be coloured before the experiment
- D Only coloured solvents can be used in it
Show answer
Why:
From the Greek chroma and graphein.
- A Water comes over first because it is more abundant
- B Both come over together and cannot be separated
- C Neither vaporises until 100 °C is reached
- D Acetone comes over first and collects in the conical flask
Show answer
Why:
Acetone has the lower boiling point of the two.
- A It measures the temperature of the cooling water
- B It stirs the mixture as it is heated
- C It reads the temperature of the vapour leaving the flask
- D It seals the top of the condenser
Show answer
Why:
That reading tells you which liquid is coming over.
- A To wash the distillate as it passes through
- B To keep the vapour hot until it reaches the flask
- C To dilute the distillate to a fixed strength
- D To carry heat away so the vapour returns to liquid
Show answer
Why:
Circulating air can serve the same purpose.
- A Free steel cylinders for storing gas
- B Equipment for fractional distillation of crude oil
- C Support in cultivating fragrance-producing plants
- D Chromatographic paper at reduced prices
Show answer
Why:
It also advises people setting up perfume businesses.
- A Either evaporation or distillation will get salt back out of a salt solution
- B Distillation separates two liquids of the same boiling point
- C The solvent level should start above the sample spot
- D Evaporation and crystallization are the same process
Show answer
Why:
The other three are the standard traps.
- A Only one component was present in the mixture
- B The two components travelled at almost the same speed
- C The solvent level was set above the spot
- D The paper strip was too wide for the container
Show answer
Why:
Their interactions with solvent and paper must be similar.
- A 2 cm, with the pencil line 3 cm from its bottom edge
- B 10 cm, with the pencil line halfway up the strip
- C 30 cm, with the pencil line near the very top
- D 3 cm, with the pencil line 2 cm from its bottom edge
Show answer
Why:
The pencil line sits 2 cm from its bottom edge.
- A A sheet of aluminium foil
- B A piece of plastic sheet
- C A strip of filter paper
- D A glass microscope slide
Show answer
Why:
The solvent must be able to rise through the material.
- A The vapour is condensed and collected rather than escaping
- B The solvent is never heated during the process
- C The solvent stays behind in the distillation flask
- D The solvent turns into a solid that can be picked up
Show answer
Why:
Evaporation lets it disappear into the air instead.
- A Only the boiling method gave varied sizes
- B Both panga and karkatch methods gave crystals of different sizes
- C Only the evaporation method gave varied sizes
- D Neither method affected crystal size
Show answer
Why:
The two were distinct processes used by coastal communities.
- A The solvent must have been too cold
- B The paper must have been the wrong width
- C The ink may be a single substance rather than a mixture
- D The pencil line must have been drawn in ink
Show answer
Why:
Separation into several spots is what reveals a mixture.
- A Condense the vapour, heat the flask, collect the residue, filter it
- B Heat the flask, vaporise the lower-boiling liquid, condense it, collect the distillate
- C Filter the mixture, heat the filtrate, cool the flask, weigh the solid
- D Cool the mixture, collect the crystals, heat them, condense the vapour
Show answer
Why:
Whatever does not vaporise stays in the distillation flask.
Important short questions (8)
Evaporation returns the solute but the solvent disappears into the air. Distillation catches the vapour and cools it back to liquid, so the solvent is recovered too. It also handles two miscible liquids, which evaporation cannot separate at all.
It is the heating of a mixture until the liquid with the lower boiling point vaporises, followed by cooling that vapour so it turns back into liquid. It allows the recovery of the solvent, the separation of liquids differing in boiling point by at least about 25 °C, and the separation of a liquid from a solution containing dissolved solids.
The vapour of the lower-boiling one is led through the condenser, chilled there by water or air kept moving around it, and runs off clean. That liquid gathers in a separate vessel, while the solid or the other liquid from the mixture remains behind in the distillation flask.
Their boiling points lie far enough apart. Acetone turns to vapour at about 56 °C while water needs 100 °C, and a gap that wide lets the acetone boil away before water is producing vapour in any quantity.
Simple distillation separates liquids whose boiling points differ by at least about 25 °C, while fractional distillation deals with relatively small differences of less than 25 °C. Crude petroleum, extracted from the Earth's crust, is split by fractional distillation into fractions such as petroleum gas, petrol, kerosene and diesel.
Cut a strip about 3 cm across from chromatographic paper, or from filter paper if none is to hand, and rule a straight horizontal line across it 2 cm up from the lower edge, using a pencil. Put a single mark from a black sketch pen at the middle of that line. Then stand the strip upright in a thin layer of water, with the level staying under the mark.
It turns on how each component gets on with the solvent and with the paper. The liquid draws the substances up the strip and sorts them by how quickly each one travels. As the water climbs, the mark begins to part into separate coloured spots, which shows it was a mixture.
Distillation cannot separate two liquids of the same boiling point, since the boiling points must differ by at least about 25 °C. The solvent level should start below the sample spot, not above it, or the ink would dissolve away into the liquid. And evaporation and crystallization are not the same process, since crystallization forms crystals from a saturated solution and yields a pure, well-shaped solid.
Long answer questions (4)
Evaporation recovers a solute such as salt but loses the solvent, and it cannot touch a mixture of two liquids that mix into one another. Distillation answers both problems.
Two liquids that mix freely can be parted by warming them until whichever boils lower goes off as vapour. That vapour is then cooled, turning back into liquid. This is distillation, and it allows the recovery of the solvent, the separation of liquids differing in boiling point by at least about 25 °C, and the separation of a liquid from a solution containing dissolved solids.
In the apparatus, the mixture sits in a distillation flask on wire gauze above a burner, with a thermometer reading the temperature of the vapour leaving it. The vapour of the lower-boiling one is led through a condenser, chilled there by water or air kept moving around it, and runs off clean. It is caught in a vessel of its own, and whatever else was in the mixture stays behind in the flask.
Acetone and water can be separated this way because their boiling points differ sufficiently, acetone boiling at about 56 °C and water at 100 °C. A large difference lets one liquid vaporise before the vapours of the other are formed in significant amount, so what comes over is essentially pure acetone.
Simple distillation needs the two boiling points to stand at least about 25 °C apart. Where they lie closer than that, another method is required.
Where the boiling points sit close together, under 25 °C apart, the method needed is fractional distillation. It is the method industry relies on for mixtures that simple distillation cannot resolve.
The standard case is petroleum. A refinery is the works in which crude oil is broken down into the various things made from it, and what comes off is a set of useful gases and liquids.
Crude petroleum is drawn out of the Earth's crust and separated into its different fractions by fractional distillation. Among them are petroleum gas, petrol, kerosene which serves as aviation fuel, diesel, lubricating oil and bitumen.
The gaseous fraction is dealt with separately. It is filled into steel cylinders under high pressure, where it gets liquefied, and in that form it is used as domestic fuel under the name Liquefied Petroleum Gas, or LPG. That is how the same process that yields road bitumen at one end also supplies the gas used for cooking at the other.
Begin with a 3 cm wide strip of chromatographic paper, or a strip of filter paper as an alternative, and rule one straight horizontal line 2 cm from the bottom using a pencil. A pencil is specified because ink would itself be carried up by the solvent.
Put a single dot of black sketch pen on the middle of that line. Pour water into a gas jar, a measuring cylinder or a beaker — just enough to cover the base.
Place the paper strip vertically in the container so that its lower end dips into the water, with the water level below the spot. This matters: if the level were above the spot, the ink would simply dissolve into the liquid instead of being carried up the paper.
Observe the strip as the water rises through it. The ink starts to separate into different colour spots, which shows that the single black mark was never one substance.
The method is called paper chromatography, and it works because each component clings to the paper, and travels with the liquid, to a different degree. The liquid draws them all upward, and they sort themselves out by how quickly each is carried. A component held more tightly by the paper lags behind, while one carried readily by the solvent travels further.
Two traditions are named here, and both rest on techniques this chapter teaches.
The first is salt. Drawing salt out as crystals is an old craft of the communities living along India's coasts. Boiling down concentrated sea brines yielded what was called panga salt, while letting seawater dry off in the open yielded karkatch, and the two routes gave crystals of differing sizes.
The second is perfume. Distillation has served many ends over a long stretch of time, among them drawing fragrance out of flowers.
Kannauj, a town in Uttar Pradesh, carries the name of India's perfume capital. The pleasing earthy scent that lifts off dry ground once the first rain falls is caught there and bottled as a natural perfume, Mitti ka Ittar. It is produced by the traditional Deg-Bhapka distillation, handed down through generations in the town, and buyers want it both within India and well beyond.
The Fragrance and Flavour Development Centre there is equipped to draw flavour and fragrance components out of flowers, leaves and other plant parts. It also backs farmers growing fragrance-bearing plants, and advises anyone hoping to start a perfume business of their own.
Flashcards (22)
Play this topic
- Separation Techniques Match
- True or False: Distillation and Chromatography
- Fill the Gaps: Separating Mixtures
- Unscramble: Separating Mixtures
Separating Heterogeneous Mixtures, Colloids and the Tyndall Effect
Two liquids that refuse to mix can be drained apart, a subliming solid can be lifted straight out as vapour, and stubborn cloudy water can be spun or clumped clear. Behind all of it lies one number: how big the particles are, which decides whether a mixture is a solution, a suspension or a colloid.
What you will be able to do
- Describe how a separating funnel parts two immiscible liquids.
- Explain sublimation and deposition, and how they separate camphor from sand.
- Distinguish a suspension from a solution, and describe centrifugation and coagulation.
- Compare solutions, suspensions and colloids by particle size and behaviour.
- Explain the Tyndall effect and say which mixtures show it.
Key points
Pour water into a vessel holding oil and the two settle into separate layers rather than blending, which is what earns them the name immiscible liquids; sand with water, and iron filings with sulfur, behave the same way.
In the activity, 5 mL of mustard oil and 20 mL of water are poured into a 50 mL separating funnel and left alone, whereupon the yellow oil takes the upper position and the water the lower.
The stopcock is eased open to run the lower layer of water off into a container, closed once the water has nearly all gone, opened again for a small middle portion that is thrown away because it holds both, and opened once more to collect the oil.
Because gas particles travel freely in every direction they blend readily and evenly with other gases, so most gas mixtures turn out homogeneous, hydrogen with oxygen for rocket fuel being one such.
Smoke, which is solid particles held up in air, fog, which is tiny droplets of water in air, and airborne dust are heterogeneous all the same, each having a gas for one of its parts.
Most solid-solid mixtures are heterogeneous, and the trick is to exploit some property one solid has and the other lacks, as a magnet exploits iron against sawdust.
Crushed camphor mixed with sand is warmed gently in a china dish under an inverted glass funnel whose nozzle is plugged with cotton, and white camphor gathers on the funnel's inner wall while the sand stays put below.
Warmed below its melting point, camphor passes straight from solid to vapour without ever being liquid, a change called sublimation; the vapour then settles back to solid without becoming liquid either, which is deposition.
Naphthalene will do the job in camphor's place, and dry ice, the solid form of carbon dioxide used for keeping ice cream, sublimes in the same way.
Metals will not dissolve in one another at ordinary temperatures, but melted and mixed they set on cooling into what looks like a single metal, and such a homogeneous mixture of metals, or of a metal with a non-metal, is an alloy that no physical method will take apart.
Brass runs to roughly 80% copper with 20% zinc, bronze to roughly 80% copper with 20% tin, and stainless steel to iron with carbon, chromium, nickel and molybdenum, all made to be stronger, more rigid or better at resisting corrosion.
A heterogeneous mixture whose solid particles stay undissolved and hang throughout the bulk of the liquid is a suspension, its particles being bigger than those in a solution and plain to the naked eye, as with sawdust or tea leaves in water.
Muddy water may stay cloudy even after standing and after passing through cloth or filter paper, which shows that filtration alone will not always take out the finest particles.
Spinning a tube at high speed swings it horizontal and throws the heavier particles outward to the bottom while the lighter liquid stays above, a technique called centrifugation that laboratories use to part blood into red cells and plasma.
The paperfuge, a hand-powered device built on the idea behind a common toy, spins blood at very high speed without any electricity and can help detect malaria and anaemia far from a laboratory.
Powdered alum, or fitkari, a white crystalline substance much used in purifying water, makes fine suspended particles clump together in a process called coagulation, and the clumps then settle under gravity to be poured or filtered off.
Turning milk into paneer works the same way, with lemon juice or vinegar acting as the coagulant on the milk proteins.
Blood can be spun apart and it coagulates, yet its cells escape the naked eye, so it is neither a true suspension nor a solution but a colloid, as milk, tomato sauce and ice cream also are.
The three families differ chiefly in particle size: under 1 nm across in a solution, between 1 and 1000 nm in a colloid, and above 1000 nm in a suspension.
Colloid particles, unlike those of a suspension, stay spread evenly through the mixture and do not drop out as time passes.
Passing a laser through the three beakers of Activity 5.1 showed no visible path in the salt solution, a clearly visible one through the chalk suspension, and a visible one through the milk mixture as well although it looked uniform.
That scattering of light by particles is the Tyndall effect, named for John Tyndall, who first explained it, and it shows itself in a sunbeam entering a dark room through a chink and in stadium floodlights.
Light is scattered by a colloid or a suspension but passes unscattered through a transparent solution.
A colloid's two parts are the dispersed phase, being the solute-like particles, and the dispersion medium, being whatever they are suspended in.
Where both parts are liquids the colloid is an emulsion, sorted into oil-in-water, as milk and vanishing creams are, and water-in-oil, as butter, body lotions and cold cream are.
Emulsifying agents hold emulsions together, proteins in milk and butter doing that work, and shaking cooking oil into water carrying a little soap solution makes one for yourself.
Full explanation
When Two Liquids Refuse to Mix
Pour water into a container that already holds oil. The two form separate layers: they do not mix, and liquids that behave this way are called immiscible.
Sand with water behaves similarly, and so do iron filings with sulfur. All are heterogeneous mixtures.
So how do you separate two immiscible liquids?
Activity 5.6: The Separating Funnel
- Put 5 mL of mustard oil and 20 mL of water together into a 50 mL separating funnel.
- Leave it alone to settle.
- Two layers form. The yellow mustard oil takes the upper position; water the lower. Can you say why?
- Ease the stopcock open and run the water off the bottom into a container, watching it as it goes.
- Shut the stopcock as the water runs out.
- Draw off the next trickle on its own — it will hold some of each — and throw it away.
- Open the stopcock again and collect the oil separately.
Two separate liquids, from one mixture. Lower first, middle away, upper last.
What if two immiscible liquids of the same density were mixed in a separating funnel? How would the layers form then?
What About Gases?
Nothing restrains a gas particle from going any way it likes, which is why one gas runs evenly through another without trouble. For that reason most mixtures of gases are homogeneous — a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, used as rocket fuel, for instance.
But not all. These are heterogeneous mixtures with a gas as one component:
- smoke — solid bits held up in air,
- fog — tiny liquid water droplets in air,
- dust in the air.
And most solid-solid mixtures are heterogeneous too. The way in is to use a property one solid has and the other lacks — a magnet separates iron nails from sawdust on exactly that principle.
Sublimation
Activity 5.7
- Put a spatula full of a mixture of crushed camphor and sand into a clean, dry china dish, and stand it on a tripod with wire gauze.
- Take a clean, dry glass funnel and plug its nozzle with cotton.
- Keep the funnel inverted over the china dish.
- Light the burner beneath the wire gauze.
- Heat the dish gently for a few minutes.
- Look carefully at the inner wall of the funnel.
You find white solid camphor deposited on the inner wall, while the sand remains in the china dish.
What happened
Warm camphor, but keep it under its melting point, and it goes straight from solid to vapour, never once being liquid. That is sublimation.
Let the vapour cool and it returns to solid the same way, skipping the liquid again. That is deposition.
Camphor sublimes and so separates from sand, because sand does not sublime on heating.
Other subliming substances work too — naphthalene, for instance. And dry ice, which is solid carbon dioxide used for storing ice cream, sublimes in the same way.
An Aside: Alloys
Can one metal dissolve in another?
Not at room temperature. Take them hot enough to run, though, and metals will dissolve in one another; let that melt cool and it sets as something new which looks like one metal and not two.
An alloy is a uniform mixture of metals, or of a metal with a non-metal.
No physical method will get the components apart again. The point of making one is usually to obtain something stronger, stiffer, or less inclined to corrode.
| Alloy | Composition (approximate) |
|---|---|
| Brass | 80% copper, 20% zinc |
| Bronze | 80% copper, 20% tin |
| Stainless steel | Iron with carbon (0.03–0.8%), chromium (16–18%), nickel (10.0–14.0%), molybdenum (2.0–3.0%) |
Suspensions
Go back to sand in water. However well you stir, the grains of sand stay plainly visible — unlike a solution, where the solute particles are not visible at all.
Where solid particles refuse to dissolve and instead hang scattered right through the liquid, the uneven mixture is called a suspension.
Their particles are larger than those in a solution, and visible to the naked eye. Sawdust in water and tea leaves in water are other examples.
The trouble with muddy water
Leave muddy water standing and the heavier particles settle, but the water may still look cloudy. Filter it through cotton cloth or filter paper and some larger particles go, but the water often remains cloudy.
That shows something important: filtration is not always enough to separate tiny particles. Two further techniques are needed.
A. Centrifugation
Hold a partner's crossed hands and spin around together. Do you feel pulled outwards? A similar force does the work here.
Centrifugation involves spinning a mixture in a tube at high speed. The tubes swing out flat, and the outward push on anything travelling in a circle throws the denser matter to the far end, where it collects at the tube's bottom, leaving the thinner liquid above it.
Laboratories use it constantly to part blood into its fractions — the red cells from the plasma — and it is standard in chemical works besides.
The paperfuge. Centrifugation usually needs an electric machine. But applying the idea behind a common toy, a simple hand-cranked device called a paperfuge does the same job without electricity. Spinning blood samples at very high speed, it separates heavier components from lighter ones just as a laboratory centrifuge does. This low-cost tool can help detect diseases such as malaria and anaemia in remote areas.
B. Coagulation
Add powdered alum (fitkari) to a beaker of muddy water. Alum comes as white crystals and is a standard thing to put in water being cleaned up.
What it does is make the fine particles gather into lumps. That process is coagulation, and the alum is then said to be a coagulant.
The larger clumps then settle by gravity — this settling is sedimentation — and can be separated from the water by decantation or filtration.
The same thing happens in a kitchen. Making paneer from milk involves coagulation too, with an acid — lemon juice or vinegar — as the coagulant, clumping the milk proteins together.
Colloids
Here is a puzzle. Blood can be separated by centrifugation, and blood coagulates. Does that make it a suspension? But blood cells cannot be seen with the naked eye. Is it then a solution?
Blood answers to neither description, being no solution and no proper suspension. It is a colloid.
Milk, tomato sauce and ice cream are colloids too.
It comes down to size
Solutions, suspensions and colloids differ mainly in the size of the dissolved or suspended particles:
| Mixture | Particle diameter |
|---|---|
| Solution | less than 1 nm |
| Colloid | 1 – 1000 nm |
| Suspension | more than 1000 nm |
And unlike a suspension, a colloid keeps its particles from settling over time. They stay uniformly dispersed throughout the mixture, as in a solution.
The Tyndall Effect
Remember the laser in Activity 5.1? Three beakers, three results:
- In solution A (salt water), the path of the beam was not visible.
- In suspension B (chalk powder), the particles scattered the beam, making its path visible.
- In mixture C (milk), the path was visible too — the particles scattered the light, even though the mixture appeared homogeneous.
When particles throw light about in this way the phenomenon carries the name of John Tyndall, who worked on precisely that and first gave the explanation — hence the Tyndall effect.
Let a narrow beam into a darkened room through a chink and you will see it, thrown about by whatever dust and smoke are hanging in the air. Or in the floodlights of a sports stadium.
Scattering occurs when light passes through a colloid or a suspension, but not through a transparent solution.
The Parts of a Colloid
- The dispersed phase is the solute-like component, the dispersed particles themselves.
- The dispersion medium is the component in which the dispersed phase is suspended.
Emulsions
Where both the dispersed phase and the dispersion medium are liquids, the colloid is called an emulsion.
Emulsions of oil and water are further classified by which liquid plays which part:
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Oil-in-water | Milk, vanishing creams |
| Water-in-oil | Butter, body lotions, cold cream |
Certain medicines are put up as emulsions so that they spread through water and go down more easily, which also takes the oiliness off a liquid dose.
Emulsifying agents stabilise emulsions. In milk and in butter it is the protein that does this work. You can get the same effect at the sink: a little cooking oil, water with a few drops of soap in it, and hard shaking.
Activity 5.9: The Summary Table
| Property | Solution | Suspension | Colloid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nature | Homogeneous | Heterogeneous | Appears homogeneous |
| Particle size | < 1 nm | > 1000 nm | 1 – 1000 nm |
| Visibility | Not visible | Visible to naked eye | Not visible |
| Separated by filtration | No | Yes | No |
| Settling | Does not settle | Settles on standing | Does not settle |
| Tyndall effect | Not shown | Shown | Shown |
Separation Beyond the Laboratory
We use properties such as size, density and solubility to separate mixtures — but it is not always simple. Try separating all the ingredients of a lemonade once they are mixed.
Separation happens in nature and in our bodies too: our kidneys remove waste from our blood.
And there are bigger tasks. Cleaning oceans and rivers of plastic waste. Treating sewage before it is released, which involves sedimentation, coagulation and filtration, after which the clean water can be reused for flushing toilets or watering plants. Sorting household waste so dry waste (plastic, paper, glass, metal) can be recycled and wet waste (food scraps, vegetable peels) composted. Researchers are even finding ways to recover lithium from old mobile phone and laptop batteries.
Concepts and terms
Two liquids that will not blend, settling instead into separate layers. Oil with water is the standard pair, and a separating funnel parts them by draining the lower layer off first.
Sublimation is a solid passing straight to vapour below its melting point without ever being liquid. Deposition is the reverse, vapour returning to solid without a liquid stage in between.
A heterogeneous mixture whose solid particles stay undissolved and hang throughout the liquid. Its particles exceed 1000 nm, are visible to the naked eye, and settle on standing.
A mixture whose particles measure between 1 and 1000 nm. They escape the naked eye and do not settle out, yet they scatter light, which is what separates a colloid from a true solution.
The scattering of light by particles, making a light beam's path visible. Colloids and suspensions show it; a transparent solution does not.
Did you know
The paperfuge, built on the idea behind a common spinning toy, separates blood without any electricity and can help detect malaria and anaemia in remote places.
The spinning game that explains centrifugation is itself a folk dance, phugadi to Marathi speakers and kikli to Punjabi ones.
Dry ice, which is solid carbon dioxide used for keeping ice cream cold, sublimes rather than melting.
Memory tricks
The three families by size — Under one, one to a thousand, over a thousand — Solution particles measure less than 1 nm, colloid particles between 1 and 1000 nm, and suspension particles more than 1000 nm across.
Which show the Tyndall effect — Cloudy or milky, the beam shows — A suspension and a colloid both scatter light so the beam's path can be seen. A transparent solution lets it through unscattered.
Using a separating funnel — Lower first, middle away, upper last — Drain the bottom layer, discard the small portion carrying both, then collect the top layer separately.
Practice MCQs with answers (40)
- A miscible, as acetone and water are
- B immiscible, as oil and water are
- C colloidal, as milk and blood are
- D homogeneous, as all solutions are
Show answer
Why:
A separating funnel is what parts them.
- A The upper layer, which is the oil
- B Both layers together, then re-separated
- C The lower layer, which is the water
- D Neither; the funnel is simply tipped
Show answer
Why:
The oil is collected last, after the middle portion is discarded.
- A deposition, which runs in the opposite direction
- B evaporation, which starts from a liquid instead
- C condensation, which finishes as a liquid instead
- D sublimation, which happens below the melting point
Show answer
Why:
It happens below the melting point of the substance.
- A Condensation, which finishes with a liquid instead
- B Deposition, vapour returning to solid with no liquid stage
- C Evaporation, which begins with a liquid instead
- D Melting, which turns a solid into a liquid
Show answer
Why:
Neither sublimation nor deposition passes through a liquid stage.
- A At the bottom of the china dish
- B On the inner wall of the inverted funnel
- C In the cotton plug at the nozzle
- D On the wire gauze beneath the dish
Show answer
Why:
The sand stays behind in the china dish.
- A an emulsion
- B a colloid
- C a suspension
- D an alloy
Show answer
Why:
Physical methods cannot separate its components.
- A visible to the naked eye and larger than a solution's
- B invisible and smaller than a solution's
- C exactly the same size as a solution's
- D always smaller than a colloid's
Show answer
Why:
They stay undissolved throughout the medium.
- A centrifugation
- B coagulation
- C sublimation
- D decantation
Show answer
Why:
The heavier particles are driven outwards.
- A a solvent
- B a solute
- C a coagulant
- D an emulsifying agent
Show answer
Why:
It makes the fine particles clump together.
- A the Brownian effect
- B the Tyndall effect
- C sedimentation
- D decantation
Show answer
Why:
John Tyndall first explained it.
- A It is the denser of the two liquids
- B It was poured in after the water
- C Its colour makes it rise to the top
- D It is the less dense of the two liquids
Show answer
Why:
A separating funnel parts immiscible liquids on their densities.
- A To stop the vapour escaping before it can deposit
- B To hold the funnel steady on the china dish
- C To filter the sand out of the mixture
- D To keep the china dish from cracking
Show answer
Why:
The camphor has to condense on the inner wall.
- A Sublimation starts from a liquid; evaporation starts from a solid
- B Both start from a solid but end differently
- C There is no difference between the two
- D Sublimation starts from a solid; evaporation starts from a liquid
Show answer
Why:
Sublimation skips the liquid state entirely.
- A Sand is lighter and settles at the bottom
- B Sand dissolves into the camphor vapour
- C Sand melts and runs to the edge of the dish
- D Sand does not sublime on heating
Show answer
Why:
The separation rests on a property one solid has and the other lacks.
- A The filter paper must have been torn
- B The water contained no particles at all
- C Filtration cannot always remove the tiniest particles
- D The mud must have dissolved completely
Show answer
Why:
Centrifugation or coagulation is needed for those.
- A At the top of the tube, above the liquid
- B Spread evenly through the liquid
- C Stuck to the walls near the mouth
- D At the bottom of the tube, driven outwards
Show answer
Why:
The lighter liquid remains above them.
- A The inward pull towards the centre of the spin
- B The upward push of the surrounding liquid
- C The downward pull of gravity alone
- D The outward force acting on a body in circular motion
Show answer
Why:
The spinning game gives the same sensation.
- A Its cells escape the naked eye, yet it can be spun apart and coagulates
- B Its cells are clearly visible, like a suspension's particles
- C It dissolves completely, like a true solution
- D It scatters no light at all when a beam passes through
Show answer
Why:
It fits neither the solution nor the suspension description.
- A 1 to 1000 nm
- B less than 1 nm
- C more than 1000 nm
- D exactly 1 nm
Show answer
Why:
A solution's are smaller and a suspension's larger.
- A Chalk powder stirred into water
- B A transparent salt solution
- C Milk diluted with water
- D Dusty air in a dark room
Show answer
Why:
Its particles are too small to scatter the light.
- A 2 and 3 only
- B 1 and 2 only
- C 1 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Colloid particles stay evenly spread and do not settle.
- A 1 and 2 only
- B 1 and 3 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
Neither change involves a liquid stage at all.
- A 1 and 3 only
- B 1 and 2 only
- C 2 and 3 only
- D 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Why:
The middle portion holds both liquids and is thrown away.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
That difference is exactly what the Tyndall effect reveals.
- A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- C A is true but R is false
- D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Why:
Filtering does nothing to a homogeneous alloy, so the assertion is false. The reason explains why.
- A Water-in-oil — milk
- B Oil-in-water — milk
- C Oil-in-water — butter
- D Water-in-oil — vanishing cream
Show answer
Why:
Butter and cold cream are water-in-oil.
- A A coagulant, such as powdered alum
- B A solvent, such as alcohol
- C An emulsifying agent, such as the proteins in milk
- D Nothing; emulsions always separate at once
Show answer
Why:
Proteins in milk and butter do this work.
- A To make them cheaper to manufacture
- B To stop them dissolving in the stomach
- C To disperse them in water and make them easier to take
- D To give them a stronger colour
Show answer
Why:
It also reduces the greasy feeling of a liquid medicine.
- A The solute and the solvent
- B The residue and the filtrate
- C The dispersed phase and the dispersion medium
- D The coagulant and the sediment
Show answer
Why:
The first is the solute-like component.
- A Only in a beaker under a laser pointer
- B In stadium floodlights and in a sunbeam entering a dark room
- C In a glass of clear drinking water
- D In a sealed container of pure oxygen
Show answer
Why:
Dust and smoke particles in the air do the scattering.
- A By dissolving both in water and filtering
- B By heating the mixture until one sublimes
- C With a magnet, using a property one solid has and the other lacks
- D By spinning the mixture in a centrifuge tube
Show answer
Why:
Most solid-solid mixtures are separated on exactly this principle.
- A They drop to the bottom within a few minutes
- B They stay evenly spread and do not settle over time
- C They can be removed by ordinary filter paper
- D They are larger than the particles of a suspension
Show answer
Why:
In this they behave like a solution rather than a suspension.
- A The particles absorb all the light that falls on them
- B The air becomes a true solution of smoke in gas
- C The particles settle instantly out of the air
- D The airborne particles scatter light, as in the Tyndall effect
Show answer
Why:
The same scattering makes stadium floodlights visible.
- A Add alum, particles dissolve, water clears at once
- B Filter first, then add alum to the filtrate
- C Add alum, particles clump, clumps settle, pour or filter off
- D Spin the water, then add alum to the clear layer
Show answer
Why:
The settling of the clumps is called sedimentation.
- A It becomes horizontal, throwing heavier particles outwards
- B It stays upright while the liquid rises
- C It tilts downwards so the liquid pours out
- D It heats up so the mixture evaporates
Show answer
Why:
Those particles then settle at the bottom of the tube.
- A A true solution, since nothing can be picked out by eye
- B An alloy, since the parts cannot be separated
- C A colloid, since the particles stay dispersed and scatter light
- D An emulsion, since both parts are liquids
Show answer
Why:
Their dispersion medium is a gas, not a liquid.
- A The particles that are suspended within the mixture
- B The component in which the dispersed particles are suspended
- C The agent added to keep the colloid stable
- D The light that is scattered as it passes through
Show answer
Why:
The dispersed phase is the solute-like component.
- A Colloid, solution, suspension
- B Suspension, colloid, solution
- C Solution, colloid, suspension
- D Solution, suspension, colloid
Show answer
Why:
Under 1 nm, then 1 to 1000 nm, then above 1000 nm.
- A Dissolve salt in water until no more will go in
- B Heat camphor gently under an inverted funnel
- C Spin a tube of muddy water at high speed
- D Shake cooking oil thoroughly with water holding a little soap solution
Show answer
Why:
The soap helps hold the two liquids together.
- A Sublimation, deposition and centrifugation
- B Sedimentation, coagulation and filtration
- C Distillation, crystallization and chromatography
- D Melting, mixing and cooling
Show answer
Why:
The clean water can then be reused for flushing or watering plants.
Important short questions (8)
The mixture is poured into the funnel and left undisturbed until two layers form, with the less dense liquid above. The stopcock is opened slowly to run the lower layer off into a container and closed when it has nearly all drained. The small portion that follows may hold both liquids and is discarded, after which the stopcock is opened again to collect the upper layer separately.
Nothing restrains a gas particle from going any way it likes, so one gas runs evenly through another without trouble — hydrogen and oxygen in rocket fuel, for instance. Smoke is solid particles suspended in air, and fog is tiny liquid water droplets in air. Smoke, fog and dust in the air are all heterogeneous, even though a gas is one of their components.
Sublimation is a solid changing directly to vapour on heating below its melting point, without passing through the liquid state, and deposition is the vapour cooling back to solid without becoming a liquid. Camphor does both, so it rises as vapour and deposits as white solid on the inner wall of the inverted funnel. Sand does not sublime on heating and remains in the china dish.
It is an uneven mixture whose solid particles will not dissolve but hang scattered right through the liquid. Its particles are larger than those in a solution and are visible to the naked eye, whereas the solute particles of a solution cannot be seen at all however closely the mixture is examined.
The mixture is spun in a tube at high speed. The tubes become horizontal and the centrifugal force, which is the outward force acting on a body in circular motion, drives the heavier particles outwards so they settle at the bottom, while the lighter liquid stays on top. Laboratories use it to part blood into its fractions, the red cells from the plasma.
Coagulation is the clumping together of fine suspended particles so they can be removed. Powdered alum, a white crystalline substance used in water purification, acts as the coagulant for muddy water, and the clumps then settle by gravity to be removed by decantation or filtration. For paneer, an acid such as lemon juice or vinegar acts as the coagulant on the milk proteins.
Solution particles measure less than 1 nm, colloid particles between 1 and 1000 nm, and suspension particles more than 1000 nm across. A suspension settles on standing, while the particles of a colloid stay uniformly dispersed throughout the mixture and do not settle over time, behaving in that respect like a solution.
It is the scattering of light by particles, named after John Tyndall who first explained it. In the salt solution the path of the laser beam was not visible, in the chalk suspension the particles scattered the beam so its path showed clearly, and in the milk mixture the path was visible too even though the mixture looked uniform. Light is scattered by a colloid or a suspension but not by a transparent solution.
Long answer questions (4)
Liquids that will not blend, such as oil and water, settle into separate layers and are called immiscible. A separating funnel exploits exactly that.
A mixture made of 5 mL mustard oil with 20 mL water is poured into a 50 mL separating funnel and left undisturbed. Two layers form, the yellow mustard oil above and the water below, the lighter liquid taking the upper position. The stopcock is opened slowly and the lower layer of water collected carefully into a container, then closed once the water has almost fully drained. The next small portion may contain both liquids and is discarded, and the stopcock is opened once more to collect the oil separately.
Sublimation handles a different case, a mixture of two solids. A spatula of crushed camphor and sand goes into a clean dry china dish on wire gauze, with a clean dry glass funnel inverted over it and its nozzle plugged with cotton. The dish is heated gently for a few minutes.
White solid camphor is found deposited on the inner wall of the funnel while the sand remains in the dish. Camphor, heated below its melting point, changes directly from solid to vapour without passing through the liquid state, which is sublimation, and on cooling those vapours return to solid without becoming liquid, which is deposition. Sand does not sublime on heating, so the two part company.
Leaving muddy water undisturbed lets the heavier particles settle, but the water may still appear cloudy. Filtering it through cotton cloth or filter paper removes some larger particles, and yet the water often remains cloudy. That shows filtration is not always enough to separate tiny particles, so two further techniques are used.
The first is centrifugation. The mixture is spun in a tube at speed; the tubes swing out flat, and the outward push on anything travelling in a circle throws the denser matter to the far end, where it collects at the tube's bottom, leaving the thinner liquid above it. Laboratories use it constantly to part blood into its fractions, the red cells from the plasma, and it is standard in chemical works besides.
The second is coagulation. Powdered alum, called fitkari, is added to the muddy water. Alum is a white crystalline substance often used in water purification, and it causes the fine suspended particles to clump together, so it acts as a coagulant. The larger clumps then settle by gravity, a process called sedimentation, and can be separated from the water by decantation or filtration.
The same idea appears in the kitchen, where making paneer from milk uses an acid such as lemon juice or vinegar to coagulate the milk proteins.
The three differ mainly in the size of the dissolved or suspended particles. In a solution the particle size is the smallest, less than 1 nm in diameter. Colloids have larger particles, between 1 and 1000 nm. Suspensions have much larger ones, more than 1000 nm across.
That difference in size shows itself in behaviour. The particles of a suspension are visible to the naked eye and settle out on standing, as sand in water does. The particles of a solution cannot be seen at all and never settle. Colloid particles, unlike those of a suspension, do not settle over time either, but stay uniformly dispersed throughout the mixture as in a solution.
A further test separates the last two cases. A colloid scatters light and so does a suspension; a clear solution does not. So the beam shows its track through the first two and leaves none through the third.
Blood sits awkwardly between the categories. It can be separated by centrifugation and it coagulates, which suggests a suspension, yet blood cells cannot be seen with the naked eye, which suggests a solution. It is in fact neither a solution nor a true suspension but a colloid, as milk, tomato sauce and ice cream also are.
When particles throw light about in this way the phenomenon carries the name of John Tyndall, who worked on precisely that and first gave the explanation, and so it is called the Tyndall effect.
Activity 5.1 demonstrated it with a laser and three beakers. In solution A, the salt and water mixture, the path of the light beam was not visible at all. In suspension B, the chalk powder in water, the particles scattered the beam and made its path visible. In mixture C, the milk in water, the path of light was visible as well, indicating that the particles scattered the light even though the mixture appeared homogeneous.
That third result is the interesting one, because it shows a mixture can look uniform to the eye and still carry particles large enough to scatter light. The general rule follows: a colloid scatters light and so does a suspension, while a clear solution does not.
The effect is easy to observe outside a laboratory. A fine beam of light entering a dark room through a small hole becomes visible because it is scattered by the dust and smoke particles in the air. The same thing makes the beams of floodlights visible in a sports stadium, and it is why cities carrying a great deal of smoke and dust in the air often look hazy.
Flashcards (22)
Play this topic
- Mixtures and Methods Match
- True or False: Colloids and Suspensions
- Fill the Gaps: Separating and Sorting
- Unscramble: Colloids and Suspensions
Class 9 Science Chapter 5 — frequently asked questions
It is a mixture whose composition is uniform throughout, so that any part of it matches any other. Vinegar, which is acetic acid in water, and aerated drinks such as soda, which hold carbon dioxide in water, are two further examples.
Because it is equally sweet in the first sip and in the last. That sameness of taste from one end of the glass to the other shows that the composition does not vary from one part of the mixture to another.
Because it is not the same throughout. You can pick out the grains by eye, and left alone they drop to the bottom. Stirring does not change either of these behaviours.
It is how much solute is carried by a stated quantity of solvent, or of the solution as a whole. It matters because the right proportion is essential when preparing a solution, whether in medicine, agriculture, food, cosmetics or even in making a cup of tea.
ORS is a measured thing: set weights of salt and sugar into a set volume of water. Alter the weights while keeping the water the same, or alter the water while keeping the weights, and what you end with is still salt and sugar dissolved in water, but it is no longer ORS. This is also why not all sugary drinks made at home or sold in shops count as ORS.
Too little pesticide may not protect the crops at all. Too much can damage the crops, the soil and the environment. So the right amount has to be mixed with a fixed amount of water, and more is not better.
Solubility is the largest quantity of solute that a fixed amount of solvent, taken as 100 mL or 100 g, will dissolve at a stated temperature. A saturated solution is one that will take up no further solute at that temperature, so anything added beyond that point stays undissolved.
Because the figure shifts as the temperature shifts. For a solid solute in a liquid solvent the solubility generally increases as things warm up, while for a gas dissolved in a liquid it generally decreases. Without a temperature the number does not say anything definite.
It is a graph of solubility against temperature, with degrees Celsius along the horizontal axis and grams of solute per 100 g of water up the vertical one. Of two curves on the same axes, the steeper one belongs to the solute whose solubility gains more from a rise in temperature.
Evaporation returns the solute but the solvent disappears into the air. Distillation catches the vapour and cools it back to liquid, so the solvent is recovered too. It also handles two miscible liquids, which evaporation cannot separate at all.
All Class 9 Science chapters
All Science chapters · Every Class 9 subject · The whole NCERT library
Study this chapter properly, free
Everything above is on this page to read. In the Veda app the same chapter becomes spaced-repetition flashcards, timed tests that mark themselves, Veda Bites you can swipe, and games — with your progress tracked topic by topic.
Get Veda free