Class 9 Mathematics Chapter 10: Combining Quantities

Combining Quantities is Chapter 10 of NCERT / CBSE Class 9 Mathematics. This page has the complete chapter notes across 3 topics , 128 practice MCQs with answers and explanations , 42 important short and long questions and 60 flashcards — all written to the NCERT / CBSE syllabus and free to read.

Weighted Average: When the Average of Averages Works

Averaging a set of averages looks like the obvious shortcut, and it is wrong more often than it is right. It gives the correct answer only when every group is the same size; the moment the groups differ, each average has to be weighted by how many values stand behind it. The same single idea settles the height of a mixed group, the strength of a blended drink, and a school report built from internals, project and final exam in a fixed ratio.

Full explanation

The shortcut that usually fails

A badminton academy has 11 trainees: 8 seniors averaging $165.5$ cm and 3 juniors averaging $149.33$ cm. Averaging the two averages gives $\dfrac{165.5 + 149.33}{2} = 157.42$ cm. Adding all eleven heights and dividing by 11 gives $161.09$ cm. These disagree, and the second is correct.

The first method fails because it treats the seniors' average and the juniors' average as equally important, when there are nearly three times as many seniors. An average carries the weight of the group behind it.

Weighting each average by its group size

Shreyas gets the right answer a shorter way:

$$\dfrac{(165.5 \times 8) + (149.33 \times 3)}{8 + 3} = \dfrac{1772}{11} = 161.09$$

Because $165.5 \times 8$ is the total height of the seniors and $149.33 \times 3$ the total height of the juniors, this is the sum of all eleven heights over 11 — Method 2 in disguise. In general, for groups of sizes $p$, $q$, $r$ with averages $a$, $b$, $c$:

$$\text{combined average} = \dfrac{ap + bq + cr}{p + q + r}$$

When the shortcut is safe

Jaspreet cycles 5 days a week for 3 weeks, averaging $12.8$, $15.8$ and $18$ minutes. Here the plain average $\dfrac{12.8 + 15.8 + 18}{3} = 15.53$ IS correct. Put $p = q = r$ into the general form and the sizes cancel:

$$\dfrac{ap + bp + cp}{3p} = \dfrac{(a + b + c)p}{3p} = \dfrac{a + b + c}{3}$$

So averaging the averages is not a wrong method — it is the special case where all the groups are the same size. Had one week held only 4 cycling days, it would fail again.

Mixtures are the same idea

Two equal glasses of lemonade, one at 10% jaggery and one at 20%, mix to 15% — midway, because the quantities are equal. Change the quantities and the answer slides towards the larger one. A 500 mL bowl at 10% mixed with a 200 mL glass at 20% gives

$$\dfrac{(0.10 \times 500) + (0.20 \times 200)}{500 + 200} = \dfrac{90}{700} = 12.86%$$

which is nearer 10% than 20%, exactly as the larger bowl demands. You can check an answer before computing it: the result must always lie between the two concentrations, and closer to whichever quantity is bigger.

Weights that are chosen, not counted

So far the weight of each value was the size of its group. It can instead be assigned. Rehmat scores 60%, 64% and 73% in internals, project and final exam, combined in the ratio $3 : 2 : 5$:

$$\dfrac{(60 \times 3) + (64 \times 2) + (73 \times 5)}{3 + 2 + 5} = \dfrac{673}{10} = 67.3%$$

Treating the three equally would have given $65.67%$. The ratio says the final exam matters five times as much as nothing in particular — it fixes the relative importance of each score, and the weighted mean is what respects it.

Watch out for these

Practice MCQs with answers (43)

Q1 A badminton group has 8 seniors averaging $165.5$ cm and 3 juniors averaging $149.33$ cm. What is the average height of all 11 trainees? beginner
  • A 149.33 cm
  • B 157.42 cm
  • C 161.09 cm
  • D 165.5 cm
Show answer
Answer: 161.09 cm
Why:

Weight each average by its group size: $\dfrac{(165.5 \times 8) + (149.33 \times 3)}{11} = \dfrac{1772}{11} = 161.09$ cm. The value $157.42$ is what you get by averaging the two averages, which ignores that there are nearly three times as many seniors.

Q2 Why does averaging the two group averages give the wrong height for the badminton group? beginner
  • A Heights cannot be averaged at all unless every single value in both of the groups is a whole number
  • B The junior average of $149.33$ has been rounded to two decimal places, so the whole discrepancy between the two methods comes from that rounding
  • C It uses division where it should have used multiplication at the very last step of the working
  • D It treats the seniors' average and the juniors' average as equally important, when there are 8 seniors and only 3 juniors
Show answer
Answer: It treats the seniors' average and the juniors' average as equally important, when there are 8 seniors and only 3 juniors
Why:

Each average carries the weight of the group behind it. Averaging the averages silently gives the 3 juniors the same say as the 8 seniors.

Q3 Jaspreet cycles 5 days a week for 3 weeks, averaging $12.8$, $15.8$ and $18$ minutes. What is her average over the 15 days? beginner
  • A 15.53 minutes
  • B 15.33 minutes
  • C 18 minutes
  • D 46.60 minutes
Show answer
Answer: 15.53 minutes
Why:

All three weeks have the same number of cycling days, so the sizes cancel and the plain average is correct: $\dfrac{12.8 + 15.8 + 18}{3} = \dfrac{46.6}{3} = 15.53$ minutes.

Q4 Averaging a set of averages gives the correct overall average in exactly which case? beginner
  • A When every group contains the same number of values
  • B When there are exactly three groups being combined
  • C When every group average is a whole number
  • D Never — it is always an incorrect method
Show answer
Answer: When every group contains the same number of values
Why:

Putting $p = q = r$ into $\dfrac{ap + bq + cr}{p + q + r}$ gives $\dfrac{(a + b + c)p}{3p} = \dfrac{a + b + c}{3}$. The sizes cancel only when they are equal.

Q5 Two collections have averages $a$ and $b$ and sizes $p$ and $q$. What is the average of the combined collection? beginner
  • A $\dfrac{ap + bq}{2}$
  • B $\dfrac{ap + bq}{p + q}$
  • C $\dfrac{a + b}{2}$
  • D $\dfrac{a + b}{p + q}$
Show answer
Answer: $\dfrac{ap + bq}{p + q}$
Why:

$ap$ is the total of the first collection and $bq$ the total of the second, so their sum over the total count $p + q$ is the combined average.

Q6 A bowl holds 500 mL of lemonade at 10% jaggery and a glass holds 200 mL at 20%. What is the concentration after mixing? intermediate
  • A 17.14%
  • B 15%
  • C 30%
  • D 12.86%
Show answer
Answer: 12.86%
Why:

$\dfrac{(0.10 \times 500) + (0.20 \times 200)}{700} = \dfrac{90}{700} = 12.86%$. It sits nearer 10% because the bowl is the larger quantity. The value $15%$ would be right only for equal quantities.

Q7 Two glasses hold EQUAL quantities of lemonade, one at 10% jaggery and one at 20%. The mixture is beginner
  • A 10%, set by the weaker glass
  • B 12.86%, nearer the weaker one
  • C 30%, the two concentrations added
  • D 15%, exactly midway between the two
Show answer
Answer: 15%, exactly midway between the two
Why:

Equal quantities give equal weights, so the result is the plain average of the two concentrations.

Q8 Rehmat scores 60%, 64% and 73% in internals, project and final exam, combined in the ratio $3 : 2 : 5$. What is her annual score? intermediate
  • A 63.4%
  • B 67.3%
  • C 73.00%
  • D 65.67%
Show answer
Answer: 67.3%
Why:

$\dfrac{(60 \times 3) + (64 \times 2) + (73 \times 5)}{3 + 2 + 5} = \dfrac{673}{10} = 67.3%$. Treating the three equally would give $65.67%$, which is lower because the best score carries the heaviest weight.

Q9 In a weighted mean, what do you divide by? beginner
  • A The sum of the weights
  • B The number of values multiplied by the largest weight
  • C The largest weight used
  • D The number of values
Show answer
Answer: The sum of the weights
Why:

Rehmat has three scores but a divisor of $3 + 2 + 5 = 10$. Dividing by 3 would discard the weighting entirely.

Q10 A customer rates food 5, service 3 and ambience 4, with weights $4 : 3 : 2$. What is the combined rating? intermediate
  • A 4.11
  • B 4.00
  • C 3.78
  • D 12.00
Show answer
Answer: 4.11
Why:

$\dfrac{(5 \times 4) + (3 \times 3) + (4 \times 2)}{4 + 3 + 2} = \dfrac{37}{9} = 4.11$.

Q11 A firm pays 6 workers ₹400 a day and 4 workers ₹550 a day. What is the average daily wage? intermediate
  • A ₹495
  • B ₹950
  • C ₹460
  • D ₹475
Show answer
Answer: ₹460
Why:

$\dfrac{(400 \times 6) + (550 \times 4)}{10} = \dfrac{4600}{10} = 460$. The plain average ₹475 ignores that more workers are on the lower wage.

Q12 A class has 20 boys averaging 48 kg and 30 girls averaging 43 kg. What is the average mass of the class? intermediate
  • A 91 kg
  • B 45.5 kg
  • C 46 kg
  • D 45 kg
Show answer
Answer: 45 kg
Why:

$\dfrac{(48 \times 20) + (43 \times 30)}{50} = \dfrac{2250}{50} = 45$ kg. The result leans towards 43 because the girls are the larger group.

Q13 Three sections of 30, 25 and 45 students average 62, 70 and 58 marks. What is the average for all 100 students? advanced
  • A 190.0
  • B 63.33
  • C 62.2
  • D 61.5
Show answer
Answer: 62.2
Why:

$\dfrac{(62 \times 30) + (70 \times 25) + (58 \times 45)}{100} = \dfrac{6220}{100} = 62.2$.

Q14 2 litres of a 30% solution are mixed with 3 litres of a 50% solution. The mixture is intermediate
  • A 40%
  • B 44%
  • C 42%
  • D 80%
Show answer
Answer: 42%
Why:

$\dfrac{(30 \times 2) + (50 \times 3)}{5} = \dfrac{210}{5} = 42%$. It lies nearer 50% because more of the stronger solution was used.

Q15 Marks of 80, 70 and 90 are combined with weights $1 : 2 : 3$. The weighted mean is intermediate
  • A 80.00
  • B 81.67
  • C 85.00
  • D 78.33
Show answer
Answer: 81.67
Why:

$\dfrac{(80 \times 1) + (70 \times 2) + (90 \times 3)}{6} = \dfrac{490}{6} = 81.67$.

Q16 A weighted average of several values can never intermediate
  • A Be smaller than the plain average of the same values
  • B Be a decimal when all the values are whole numbers
  • C Equal one of the values it was computed from
  • D Lie outside the range from the smallest value to the largest
Show answer
Answer: Lie outside the range from the smallest value to the largest
Why:

It is always between the extremes, which makes it a quick check on your arithmetic. It certainly can equal one of the values, be a decimal, or fall below the plain average.

Q17 Increasing the weight attached to one value moves the weighted mean intermediate
  • A Closer to the plain average of all the values
  • B Closer to that value
  • C Nowhere — weights change only the divisor
  • D Further away from that value
Show answer
Answer: Closer to that value
Why:

Weight measures how much say a value has. More weight, more pull towards it.

Q18 A ratio of $3 : 2 : 5$ is used as weights. Using $6 : 4 : 10$ instead would give intermediate
  • A An answer that comes out exactly half as large as before
  • B An answer that comes out exactly twice as large as before
  • C A different answer, because the divisor has changed from 10 to 20
  • D Exactly the same answer, since only the relative sizes matter
Show answer
Answer: Exactly the same answer, since only the relative sizes matter
Why:

Doubling every weight doubles the numerator and the denominator alike, so the quotient is unchanged. Weights fix relative importance only.

Q19 250 g of a 12% alloy is combined with 750 g of a 4% alloy. The combined percentage is advanced
  • A 8%
  • B 6%
  • C 5%
  • D 16%
Show answer
Answer: 6%
Why:

$\dfrac{(12 \times 250) + (4 \times 750)}{1000} = \dfrac{6000}{1000} = 6%$. It is close to 4% because three-quarters of the mass is the weaker alloy.

Q20 12 boys average 68 marks and 18 girls average 63. The class average is intermediate
  • A 68
  • B 65
  • C 65.5
  • D 66
Show answer
Answer: 65
Why:

$\dfrac{(68 \times 12) + (63 \times 18)}{30} = \dfrac{1950}{30} = 65$.

Q21 Two groups have averages 40 and 60. Without knowing the group sizes, what can you say about the combined average? intermediate
  • A It is more than 50, because the larger average pulls harder
  • B It lies somewhere between 40 and 60
  • C Nothing at all can be said about it
  • D It is exactly 50, the halfway point
Show answer
Answer: It lies somewhere between 40 and 60
Why:

It must lie between the two, and where exactly depends on the sizes. It is 50 only when the groups are equal.

Q22 A student divides $(60 \times 3) + (64 \times 2) + (73 \times 5)$ by 3 instead of by 10. The answer will be intermediate
  • A Negative, because the weights no longer balance
  • B Slightly too small, because a little of the weight has been left out of the sum
  • C Far too large, because the divisor is much smaller than the total weight
  • D Correct, since there are exactly three separate scores being averaged here
Show answer
Answer: Far too large, because the divisor is much smaller than the total weight
Why:

$673 \div 3 = 224.33$ against the correct $67.3$. Dividing by the number of values rather than the total weight is the commonest error in this topic.

Q23 For the plain average of three group averages to be correct, the group sizes must satisfy intermediate
  • A $p + q + r = 1$
  • B $p + q + r = 3$
  • C $p = q = r$
  • D $p > q > r$
Show answer
Answer: $p = q = r$
Why:

Only equal sizes cancel in $\dfrac{ap + bq + cr}{p + q + r}$.

Q24 Jaspreet cycles 5 days in week 1, 5 in week 2 but only 4 in week 3. The plain average of her three weekly averages is now intermediate
  • A Still correct, provided that all three averages are given to the same accuracy
  • B No longer correct, because the three weeks are different sizes
  • C Correct only if week 3 has the smallest average
  • D Still correct, because she did some cycling in every one of the three weeks
Show answer
Answer: No longer correct, because the three weeks are different sizes
Why:

The moment the group sizes differ, each weekly average must be weighted by its own number of days.

Q25 Assertion (A): Averaging a set of averages can give a wrong overall average. Reason (R): Each average carries the weight of the number of values behind it. beginner
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both are true and R is exactly why A happens — ignoring the weights is what makes the shortcut fail.

Q26 Assertion (A): A weighted mean always lies between the smallest and the largest of its values. Reason (R): A weighted mean is divided by the number of values. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is true but R is false
Why:

A is true and is a useful check. R is false: the divisor is the sum of the weights, not the number of values.

Q27 Assertion (A): Mixing equal quantities of 10% and 20% lemonade gives 15%. Reason (R): A weighted mean always lies between the values it combines. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both statements are true, but R only places the answer somewhere between 10% and 20%. It does not explain why this one lands exactly at the midpoint, which it does because the equal quantities give equal weights.

Q28 Assertion (A): Using weights $6 : 4 : 10$ instead of $3 : 2 : 5$ changes the weighted mean. Reason (R): Weights fix only the relative importance of the values. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is false but R is true
Why:

A is false — doubling every weight leaves the quotient unchanged. R is true and is exactly why A is false.

Q29 Assertion (A): In the badminton group the combined average $161.09$ cm lies nearer the senior average than the junior one. Reason (R): That combined average lies between $149.33$ cm and $165.5$ cm. beginner
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both statements are true, but R says only that the answer is somewhere between the two group averages. What makes it nearer the SENIOR figure is that there are more seniors than juniors.

Q30 Which expression gives the average height of the whole badminton group? intermediate
  • A $\dfrac{165.5 + 149.33}{8}$
  • B $\dfrac{(165.5 \times 3) + (149.33 \times 8)}{8 + 3}$
  • C $\dfrac{(165.5 \times 8) + (149.33 \times 3)}{8 + 3}$
  • D $\dfrac{165.5 + 149.33}{2}$
Show answer
Answer: $\dfrac{(165.5 \times 8) + (149.33 \times 3)}{8 + 3}$
Why:

Each average is multiplied by the size of its OWN group. Swapping the weights, as the third option does, gives $153.56$ cm.

Q31 A mixture of two solutions comes out at exactly the midpoint of their concentrations. This tells you that intermediate
  • A Equal quantities of the two were used
  • B The two concentrations were equal to begin with
  • C One of the quantities must have been zero
  • D The stronger solution was used in greater quantity
Show answer
Answer: Equal quantities of the two were used
Why:

The midpoint is reached exactly when the weights are equal, which here means equal quantities.

Q32 The weights in a weighted mean represent beginner
  • A The relative importance given to each value
  • B The order in which the values were collected
  • C The difference between each value and the mean
  • D The number of decimal places each value is written to
Show answer
Answer: The relative importance given to each value
Why:

A ratio such as $3 : 2 : 5$ states how much say each component has in the final figure.

Q33 In a 100 g mixture that is 6% salt, the mass of salt is beginner
  • A 60 g
  • B 0.06 g
  • C 6 g
  • D 94 g
Show answer
Answer: 6 g
Why:

6% of 100 g is 6 g. Percentage concentration is grams of substance per 100 g of mixture.

Q34 Two groups of sizes 10 and 40 have averages 80 and 50. The combined average is closest to intermediate
  • A 72
  • B 65
  • C 50
  • D 56
Show answer
Answer: 56
Why:

$\dfrac{(80 \times 10) + (50 \times 40)}{50} = \dfrac{2800}{50} = 56$, which sits near 50 because four-fifths of the values are in that group.

Q35 Which of these is NOT a situation where a weighted mean is needed? intermediate
  • A Finding the average height of two classes of different sizes
  • B Finding the average of five test marks that all count equally
  • C Mixing unequal quantities of two solutions of different strengths
  • D Combining internals, project and exam in a fixed ratio
Show answer
Answer: Finding the average of five test marks that all count equally
Why:

Equal weights reduce the weighted mean to the plain average, so no weighting is needed. The other three all have unequal weights.

Q36 A shopkeeper mixes 8 kg of rice at ₹60 per kg with 12 kg at ₹45 per kg. The cost per kg of the mixture is intermediate
  • A ₹51
  • B ₹50
  • C ₹52.50
  • D ₹60
Show answer
Answer: ₹51
Why:

$\dfrac{(60 \times 8) + (45 \times 12)}{20} = \dfrac{1020}{20} = 51$ per kg.

Q37 If one group is very much larger than the other, the combined average will be intermediate
  • A Very close to the smaller group's own average
  • B Very close to the average of the larger group
  • C Exactly midway between the two group averages
  • D Larger than both of the group averages
Show answer
Answer: Very close to the average of the larger group
Why:

The larger group holds most of the values, so it dominates the total and pulls the result to itself.

Q38 A weighted mean is computed with weights 0, 1 and 1 for three values. This is the same as advanced
  • A The largest of the three values
  • B Zero, because one weight is zero
  • C The plain average of all three values
  • D The plain average of the last two values only
Show answer
Answer: The plain average of the last two values only
Why:

A weight of 0 removes that value from both the numerator and the divisor, leaving an equally weighted mean of the remaining two.

Q39 Two sections sat the same paper. Section A averaged 70 with 20 students and Section B averaged 70 with 35 students. The combined average is intermediate
  • A 69.4
  • B 140
  • C 70
  • D 70 only if both sections are the same size
Show answer
Answer: 70
Why:

When the averages are equal, the sizes make no difference at all — any weighted mean of 70 and 70 is 70.

Q40 The expression $\dfrac{ap + bq}{p + q}$ equals $\dfrac{a + b}{2}$ precisely when advanced
  • A $p + q = 1$
  • B $p + q = 2$
  • C $p = q$
  • D $a = b$
Show answer
Answer: $p = q$
Why:

Substituting $p = q$ gives $\dfrac{(a + b)p}{2p} = \dfrac{a + b}{2}$. Note that $a = b$ makes both sides equal $a$, but it does not make the two EXPRESSIONS identical in general.

Q41 A pupil writes the combined average of the badminton group as $\dfrac{165.5 + 149.33}{8 + 3}$. The answer will be advanced
  • A Far too small, because the totals of the groups were never formed
  • B Far too large, because the divisor is too small
  • C Correct, since both the heights and the counts appear
  • D Correct only if the two groups were the same size
Show answer
Answer: Far too small, because the totals of the groups were never formed
Why:

$\dfrac{314.83}{11} = 28.6$ cm. Adding the two averages gives the sum of two numbers, not the sum of eleven heights; each average must first be multiplied by its own group size.

Q42 Three machines produce 100, 200 and 700 items with defect rates 5%, 4% and 1%. The overall defect rate is advanced
  • A 10%
  • B 3.33%
  • C 1.9%
  • D 2%
Show answer
Answer: 2%
Why:

$\dfrac{(5 \times 100) + (4 \times 200) + (1 \times 700)}{1000} = \dfrac{2000}{1000} = 2%$. It sits near 1% because the third machine makes 70% of the items.

Q43 Which quantity acts as the weight when two groups of people are combined? beginner
  • A The average for each group
  • B The number of people in each group
  • C The total of the two group averages
  • D The difference between the two group averages
Show answer
Answer: The number of people in each group
Why:

Each average is weighted by how many values stand behind it, which for a group of people is simply its size.

Important short questions (10)

Explain why the average of two group averages is not always the average of the whole collection.

Averaging the two averages gives each group equal say, but a group with more values contributes more to the total. Each average must therefore be weighted by the size of its own group.

A class has 20 boys averaging 48 kg and 30 girls averaging 43 kg. Find the average mass of the class.

$\dfrac{(48 \times 20) + (43 \times 30)}{50} = \dfrac{2250}{50} = 45$ kg.

State the one condition under which averaging a set of averages is correct, and explain briefly why.

All the groups must be the same size. Writing the combined average as $\dfrac{ap + bp + cp}{3p}$ shows the common size $p$ cancels, leaving $\dfrac{a + b + c}{3}$.

Rehmat scores 60%, 64% and 73% combined in the ratio $3 : 2 : 5$. Find her annual score.

$\dfrac{(60 \times 3) + (64 \times 2) + (73 \times 5)}{10} = \dfrac{673}{10} = 67.3%$.

500 mL of lemonade at 10% jaggery is mixed with 200 mL at 20%. Find the concentration of the mixture, and say without further calculation whether it should be above or below 15%.

It must be below 15%, because there is more of the weaker lemonade. $\dfrac{(10 \times 500) + (20 \times 200)}{700} = \dfrac{9000}{700} = 12.86%$.

A firm pays 6 workers ₹400 a day and 4 workers ₹550 a day. Find the average daily wage, and explain why it is not ₹475.

$\dfrac{(400 \times 6) + (550 \times 4)}{10} = \dfrac{4600}{10} = 460$. It is not ₹475 because more workers are on the lower wage, so that wage carries the heavier weight.

Show that using weights $6 : 4 : 10$ gives the same weighted mean as using $3 : 2 : 5$.

With weights $6, 4, 10$ the mean is $\dfrac{6x_1 + 4x_2 + 10x_3}{20} = \dfrac{2(3x_1 + 2x_2 + 5x_3)}{2 \times 10} = \dfrac{3x_1 + 2x_2 + 5x_3}{10}$, which is the mean with weights $3, 2, 5$. Multiplying every weight by the same number leaves the quotient unchanged.

Three sections of 30, 25 and 45 students average 62, 70 and 58 marks. Find the average for all 100 students and state which section pulls the result down most.

$\dfrac{(62 \times 30) + (70 \times 25) + (58 \times 45)}{100} = \dfrac{6220}{100} = 62.2$. The third section pulls hardest: it has both the lowest average and the most students.

Explain why a weighted mean can never be greater than the largest of its values.

Replacing every value by the largest, $M$, gives $\dfrac{M\sum w_i}{\sum w_i} = M$. Since the actual values are all at most $M$, the weighted mean is at most $M$.

A student computes Rehmat's score as $673 \div 3$. Identify the error and give its effect.

The divisor should be the total weight $3 + 2 + 5 = 10$, not the number of scores. Dividing by 3 gives $224.33$, which is impossible since no score exceeds 73%.

Long answer questions (4)

Answer each part in full. (i) Define a weighted mean and state what you divide by. (ii) A badminton group has 8 seniors averaging $165.5$ cm and 3 juniors averaging $149.33$ cm. Find the average height of the group. (iii) Another student answers $157.42$ cm. Explain precisely what they did and why it fails. (iv) State the condition under which their method would have been correct.

(i) A weighted mean multiplies each value by its weight, adds the products, and divides by the SUM OF THE WEIGHTS. (ii) $\dfrac{(165.5 \times 8) + (149.33 \times 3)}{11} = \dfrac{1772}{11} = 161.09$ cm. (iii) They averaged the two group averages, $\dfrac{165.5 + 149.33}{2} = 157.42$. This gives the 3 juniors the same influence as the 8 seniors, so the result is pulled too far down. (iv) It would be correct if both groups had the same number of trainees.

Answer each part in full. (i) Starting from the general form $\dfrac{ap + bq + cr}{p + q + r}$, show that equal group sizes reduce it to the plain average. (ii) Jaspreet cycles 5 days a week for 3 weeks, averaging 12.8, 15.8 and 18 minutes. Find her overall average. (iii) Week 3 is changed to 4 cycling days. Explain what must now be done differently.

(i) Putting $p = q = r$ gives $\dfrac{ap + bp + cp}{3p} = \dfrac{(a + b + c)p}{3p} = \dfrac{a + b + c}{3}$. (ii) The weeks are equal in size, so the plain average is correct: $\dfrac{12.8 + 15.8 + 18}{3} = 15.53$ minutes. (iii) The sizes are now 5, 5 and 4, so the shortcut no longer applies. Each weekly average must be weighted by its own number of days: $\dfrac{(12.8 \times 5) + (15.8 \times 5) + (18 \times 4)}{14}$.

Answer each part in full. (i) Two glasses hold equal quantities of lemonade at 10% and 20% jaggery. State the concentration of the mixture and why. (ii) A 500 mL bowl at 10% is mixed with a 200 mL glass at 20%. Predict whether the result is above or below 15%, then compute it. (iii) Explain in one sentence how a weighted mean lets you check an answer before you compute it.

(i) 15%. Equal quantities give equal weights, so the result is the plain average of 10 and 20. (ii) Below 15%, since there is more of the weaker lemonade. $\dfrac{(10 \times 500) + (20 \times 200)}{700} = \dfrac{9000}{700} = 12.86%$. (iii) The answer must always lie between the two values and nearer the one with the greater weight, so a result outside that range, or on the wrong side of the midpoint, is certainly an error.

Answer each part in full. (i) Rehmat scores 60%, 64% and 73% in internals, project and final exam, combined in the ratio $3 : 2 : 5$. Find her annual score. (ii) Find what she would have scored had the three counted equally, and explain the difference. (iii) Show that weights of $6 : 4 : 10$ give the same answer as $3 : 2 : 5$.

(i) $\dfrac{(60 \times 3) + (64 \times 2) + (73 \times 5)}{10} = \dfrac{673}{10} = 67.3%$. (ii) Equal weights give $\dfrac{60 + 64 + 73}{3} = 65.67%$. The weighted score is higher because her best mark, 73%, carries the heaviest weight of 5. (iii) $\dfrac{(60 \times 6) + (64 \times 4) + (73 \times 10)}{20} = \dfrac{1346}{20} = 67.3%$. Every weight has been doubled, so numerator and denominator both double and the quotient is unchanged.

Flashcards (20)

What is a weighted average?
An average in which each value is multiplied by a weight before adding, and the total is divided by the sum of the weights rather than by how many values there are.
When does averaging a set of averages give the correct overall average?
Only when every group contains the same number of values. Then the sizes cancel and the plain average is correct.
What is the combined average of two groups with averages $a$, $b$ and sizes $p$, $q$?
$\dfrac{ap + bq}{p + q}$ — each average multiplied by its own group size, over the total count.
In the badminton example, what is the average height of all 11 trainees?
$161.09$ cm, from $\dfrac{(165.5 \times 8) + (149.33 \times 3)}{11}$.
Why is $157.42$ cm wrong for the badminton group?
It averages the two group averages, giving the 3 juniors as much say as the 8 seniors.
Jaspreet cycles 5 days a week for 3 weeks, averaging 12.8, 15.8 and 18 minutes. What is her overall average?
$15.53$ minutes. The plain average is correct here because all three weeks have 5 cycling days.
What do you divide by in a weighted mean?
The sum of the weights — not the number of values.
Mixing equal quantities of 10% and 20% lemonade gives what concentration?
15%, exactly midway, because equal quantities mean equal weights.
Mixing 500 mL at 10% with 200 mL at 20% gives what concentration?
$12.86\%$, from $\dfrac{90}{700}$. It sits nearer 10% because the bowl is larger.
Rehmat scores 60%, 64%, 73% with weights $3 : 2 : 5$. What is her annual score?
$67.3\%$, from $\dfrac{673}{10}$.
What would Rehmat have scored if all three counted equally?
$65.67\%$ — lower, because her best score would no longer carry the heaviest weight.
What do the weights in a weighted mean represent?
The relative importance given to each value — a group size, a quantity, or a number fixed by a ratio.
Does using $6 : 4 : 10$ instead of $3 : 2 : 5$ change the answer?
No. Doubling every weight doubles the numerator and the denominator alike, so the result is identical.
Can a weighted mean lie outside the range of its values?
Never. It always falls between the smallest and the largest, which makes it a quick check on your arithmetic.
Increasing the weight on one value moves the mean which way?
Closer to that value. More weight means more pull.
A customer rates food 5, service 3, ambience 4 with weights $4 : 3 : 2$. What is the rating?
$4.11$, from $\dfrac{37}{9}$.
Why does the general form $\dfrac{ap + bp + cp}{3p}$ simplify?
Because all three sizes are the same $p$, which cancels, leaving $\dfrac{a + b + c}{3}$.
A weight of 0 is given to one of three values. What happens?
That value drops out of both the numerator and the divisor, leaving an equally weighted mean of the other two.
Two groups both average 70. Does the combined average depend on their sizes?
No. Any weighted mean of 70 and 70 is 70, whatever the weights.
What is the first check to make before computing a weighted mean?
Whether the weights are all equal. If they are, the plain average is correct and nothing further is needed.

Play this topic

  • Term and meaning
  • True or false
  • Fill in the blank
  • Unscramble the term

Stacked Columns: Comparing Totals Without Losing the Parts

The same table can be drawn as a chart in more than one way, and the choice decides which questions become easy. Clustering by family answers questions about one household; clustering by category compares the same cost across households. Stacking the bars instead gives something neither does — the total for each family at a glance — but it does so by giving up the common baseline, so every segment after the first starts somewhere awkward and becomes harder to read.

Full explanation

One table, two cluster charts

Table 10.2 gives the weekly spending of three families across six categories. Drawn as a cluster-column chart there are two sensible choices, and they are not interchangeable.

Cluster by family. Each family gets its own group of six bars. It is easy to see what a single household spends on everything, and awkward to compare one category across households because those bars sit in different groups.

Cluster by category. Each category gets its own group of three bars. Now "which family spent least on housing?" is read off at a glance — Family C, at ₹950 — and the single-household view is the awkward one.

Neither chart is better. Each makes one kind of question easy and the other kind harder, so the right question to ask is what the reader needs to find.

Stacking the bars

A stacked bar chart joins the bars of a cluster end to end instead of standing them side by side. The full height is then the family's total spending:

$$1940 + 1700 + 1280 + 1200 + 1770 + 535 = 8425$$

and Family B's 7286 and Family C's 7040 can be compared against it immediately. That is the thing a stacked chart does that neither cluster chart does well.

It also lets you judge a part against its whole. Family A's housing bar occupies $\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 23.0%$ of the stack, and recreation only $6.4%$, and both can be estimated by eye without any arithmetic.

What stacking costs

Only the first segment starts at zero. Every segment above it begins wherever the one below happened to end, so reading its length means subtracting two awkward numbers rather than reading a height. Worse, segments in different stacks have no common base at all: Family A's education block and Family B's education block start at different heights, so they cannot be compared by eye.

So the trade is exact, and it is worth stating plainly:

cluster chart stacked chart
compare one category across families easy hard
compare totals hard easy
judge a part against its whole hard easy

Reading a real one

The IUCN Red List chart in Exercise Set 10.4 stacks eight classes of animal across five years. The totals — 7851, 9618, 11212, 12630 and 14234 — are the point of the chart, and they rise by 6383 species, about $81%$, in twelve years. Picking out how many of those were molluscs in 2013 is exactly the task the stacking makes hard.

Watch out for these

Practice MCQs with answers (43)

Q1 In a stacked column chart, what does the full height of one column represent? beginner
  • A The average of its segments
  • B The number of segments it contains
  • C The total of all its segments
  • D The largest of its segments
Show answer
Answer: The total of all its segments
Why:

Family A's column reaches $1940 + 1700 + 1280 + 1200 + 1770 + 535 = 8425$.

Q2 Which family spent the least on housing? beginner
  • A They each spent the same on housing
  • B Family C, at ₹950
  • C Family A, at ₹1940
  • D Family B, at ₹1750
Show answer
Answer: Family C, at ₹950
Why:

Housing is 1940 for A, 1750 for B and 950 for C.

Q3 Which family spent the most on healthcare? beginner
  • A Family B, at ₹1210
  • B Families A and C spent the same
  • C Family C, at ₹1300
  • D Family A, at ₹1770
Show answer
Answer: Family A, at ₹1770
Why:

Healthcare is 1770 for A, 1210 for B and 1300 for C.

Q4 What is Family A's total weekly expenditure? intermediate
  • A ₹8245
  • B ₹7040
  • C ₹8425
  • D ₹7286
Show answer
Answer: ₹8425
Why:

$1940 + 1700 + 1280 + 1200 + 1770 + 535 = 8425$.

Q5 Which family has the SMALLEST total weekly expenditure? intermediate
  • A Family A, at ₹8425
  • B Families B and C are equal
  • C Family B, at ₹7286
  • D Family C, at ₹7040
Show answer
Answer: Family C, at ₹7040
Why:

Totals are 8425, 7286 and 7040, so Family C spends least overall.

Q6 A stacked bar chart is the right choice when you mainly want to intermediate
  • A Avoid using a vertical scale at all
  • B Compare one category across groups as accurately as possible
  • C Compare the totals while still seeing the parts that make them up
  • D Show a single value changing smoothly over time
Show answer
Answer: Compare the totals while still seeing the parts that make them up
Why:

Stacking buys the total and the part-to-whole view; it sells the common baseline.

Q7 Why is the second segment of a stacked column harder to read than the first? intermediate
  • A It is always drawn in a much lighter colour than the segment below it
  • B It is always shorter than whichever segment happens to be printed below it
  • C It is measured on a different vertical scale from the first
  • D It does not begin at zero, so its length is a difference rather than a height
Show answer
Answer: It does not begin at zero, so its length is a difference rather than a height
Why:

Only the bottom segment starts at zero. Every other one begins where the one below ended.

Q8 Family A's housing spending is what share of Family A's total? advanced
  • A 23.0%
  • B 26.5%
  • C 8.4%
  • D 19.4%
Show answer
Answer: 23.0%
Why:

$\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 0.230$, so 23.0%.

Q9 Family B spends nothing on recreation. On a stacked chart this appears as intermediate
  • A The category being dropped from the key
  • B A segment drawn below the axis
  • C A gap left in the middle of the column
  • D A segment of zero length
Show answer
Answer: A segment of zero length
Why:

The category remains in the chart; its segment simply has no length.

Q10 Clustering the chart BY CATEGORY rather than by family makes which question easier? intermediate
  • A Which category Family A spent least on
  • B What Family A spent across all six categories
  • C Which family spent least on housing
  • D What the three families spent in total
Show answer
Answer: Which family spent least on housing
Why:

Clustering by category puts the three families' housing bars side by side on a common base.

Q11 Which family spent the most on education? beginner
  • A Families B and C spent the same
  • B Family B, at ₹1500
  • C Family C, at ₹1540
  • D Family A, at ₹1280
Show answer
Answer: Family C, at ₹1540
Why:

Education is 1280 for A, 1500 for B and 1540 for C.

Q12 Two segments in DIFFERENT stacked columns cannot be compared reliably by eye because intermediate
  • A One of them is always the bottom segment
  • B They begin at different heights, so there is no common base
  • C They are always drawn at different widths
  • D They are measured in different units
Show answer
Answer: They begin at different heights, so there is no common base
Why:

Without a shared starting point the eye has nothing to judge the two lengths against.

Q13 The IUCN chart totals rise from 7851 in 2007 to 14234 in 2019. The increase is intermediate
  • A 6383 species
  • B 6833 species
  • C 14234 species
  • D 5383 species
Show answer
Answer: 6383 species
Why:

$14234 - 7851 = 6383$.

Q14 Approximately what percentage rise do the IUCN totals show from 2007 to 2019? advanced
  • A About 81%
  • B About 181%
  • C About 64%
  • D About 45%
Show answer
Answer: About 81%
Why:

$\dfrac{6383}{7851} = 0.813$, a rise of about 81%.

Q15 On a stacked column, the TOP of the third segment tells you intermediate
  • A The average of the first three segments
  • B The value of the third segment alone
  • C The running total of the first three segments
  • D The total of the whole column
Show answer
Answer: The running total of the first three segments
Why:

Heights on a stacked chart are cumulative; a single value is a difference of two of them.

Q16 To read the length of a middle segment from a stacked chart you should beginner
  • A Subtract the reading where it begins from the reading where it ends
  • B Add together the readings taken at its top and at its bottom
  • C Read the height at the top of the segment
  • D Divide the top reading by the bottom reading
Show answer
Answer: Subtract the reading where it begins from the reading where it ends
Why:

Only the bottom segment can be read directly as a height.

Q17 Which family spent the most on recreation? beginner
  • A Family C, at ₹150
  • B Family B, at ₹0
  • C Family A, at ₹535
  • D Families A and C spent the same
Show answer
Answer: Family A, at ₹535
Why:

Recreation is 535 for A, 0 for B and 150 for C.

Q18 A cluster-column chart of this table could be built in two ways. Those two ways are beginner
  • A Clustering by family, or clustering by category
  • B Clustering by amount, or clustering by rank
  • C Clustering by total, or clustering by average
  • D Clustering vertically, or clustering horizontally
Show answer
Answer: Clustering by family, or clustering by category
Why:

The six categories can group inside each family, or the three families inside each category.

Q19 Family C's total is ₹7040 and its transport spending is ₹1400. Transport is about what share? advanced
  • A About 7%
  • B About 20%
  • C About 25%
  • D About 14%
Show answer
Answer: About 20%
Why:

$\dfrac{1400}{7040} = 0.199$, so about 20%.

Q20 Which of these is a genuine DISADVANTAGE of a stacked column chart? intermediate
  • A It cannot be used when one of the values is zero
  • B Only the bottom segment shares the chart's zero baseline
  • C It cannot display more than three categories at once
  • D The total of a column cannot be read from it
Show answer
Answer: Only the bottom segment shares the chart's zero baseline
Why:

Losing the common baseline for every segment above the first is the real cost.

Q21 Assertion (A): A stacked column chart makes it easy to compare totals. Reason (R): The segments are drawn in the same order in every column. beginner
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both statements are true, but the shared order helps you find a category, not compare totals. What makes totals easy is that the full height of a column is the sum of its segments.

Q22 Assertion (A): Only the bottom segment of a stacked column can be read directly as a height. Reason (R): Every segment of a stacked column begins at the chart's zero line. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is true but R is false
Why:

A is true. R is false, and is in fact the opposite of the truth: only the bottom segment begins at zero, which is precisely why it is the only one readable directly.

Q23 Assertion (A): A cluster-column chart is always better than a stacked one. Reason (R): Cluster charts give every bar a common baseline. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is false but R is true
Why:

A is false — each chart makes different questions easy. R is true and is why cluster charts compare well.

Q24 Assertion (A): Family B's recreation segment has zero length. Reason (R): Family B spent nothing on recreation that week. beginner
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both true, and R is the reason: a zero value draws as a segment of no length.

Q25 Assertion (A): Family A's education segment and Family B's begin at different heights on the chart. Reason (R): A length can be judged reliably by eye wherever it begins. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is true but R is false
Why:

A is true, since each segment sits on top of whatever came before it. R is false: the eye needs a common baseline, which is exactly why these two cannot be compared.

Q26 Which category did Family B spend the MOST on? intermediate
  • A Food, at ₹1546
  • B Education, at ₹1500
  • C Housing, at ₹1750
  • D Healthcare, at ₹1210
Show answer
Answer: Housing, at ₹1750
Why:

Family B's row is 1750, 1546, 1500, 1280, 1210, 0, so housing is highest.

Q27 What is the combined weekly spending of all three families? advanced
  • A ₹22751
  • B ₹22571
  • C ₹21751
  • D ₹23751
Show answer
Answer: ₹22751
Why:

$8425 + 7286 + 7040 = 22751$.

Q28 A chart is needed to answer "which family spends most overall?". The best choice is intermediate
  • A A cluster chart grouped by family, with six bars standing in each group
  • B A stacked column chart, where the total is the column height
  • C A cluster chart grouped by category, with one group for each of them
  • D A chart with no vertical axis at all
Show answer
Answer: A stacked column chart, where the total is the column height
Why:

Totals are exactly what stacking shows at a glance.

Q29 Family A spends ₹535 on recreation out of ₹8425. As a share of the total this is closest to advanced
  • A 11%
  • B 2%
  • C 16%
  • D 6%
Show answer
Answer: 6%
Why:

$\dfrac{535}{8425} = 0.064$, so about 6%.

Q30 In a stacked column chart, the ORDER in which the segments are stacked advanced
  • A Must always run from the largest segment down to the smallest one
  • B Changes the total height of the column
  • C Has no effect on the chart at all
  • D Changes which segments are easy to read, but not the total
Show answer
Answer: Changes which segments are easy to read, but not the total
Why:

The sum is unchanged, but whichever category is placed at the bottom gains the zero baseline.

Q31 Which family spent the LEAST on transportation? beginner
  • A Families A and B spent the same
  • B Family A, at ₹1200
  • C Family C, at ₹1400
  • D Family B, at ₹1280
Show answer
Answer: Family A, at ₹1200
Why:

Transportation is 1200 for A, 1280 for B and 1400 for C.

Q32 Comparing a single segment with the whole column lets you estimate intermediate
  • A What fraction of the total that component makes up
  • B The average spending across all the families
  • C The exact value in rupees of that one component
  • D How many separate categories the whole chart contains
Show answer
Answer: What fraction of the total that component makes up
Why:

Part against whole is read by eye; the exact value still needs the scale.

Q33 The IUCN chart shows totals for five years. Reading how many MOLLUSCS there were in 2013 is intermediate
  • A Exact, because each segment is printed with its own number
  • B Impossible, because the chart shows only totals
  • C Harder, because that segment does not start at zero
  • D Easier, because molluscs are stacked at the very bottom
Show answer
Answer: Harder, because that segment does not start at zero
Why:

It is a middle segment, so its length must be found as a difference of two cumulative readings.

Q34 Family B's total is ₹7286. Housing takes ₹1750 of it, which is closest to advanced
  • A 14%
  • B 24%
  • C 29%
  • D 19%
Show answer
Answer: 24%
Why:

$\dfrac{1750}{7286} = 0.240$, about 24%.

Q35 Which statement about the three family totals is correct? intermediate
  • A Family C spends most and Family B least
  • B Family A spends most and Family C least
  • C All three families spend about the same
  • D Family B spends most and Family A least
Show answer
Answer: Family A spends most and Family C least
Why:

The totals are A 8425, B 7286 and C 7040.

Q36 If one more category were added to the table, a stacked column would intermediate
  • A Have to be redrawn as a cluster chart
  • B Lose its zero baseline entirely
  • C Keep the same height and squeeze the other segments
  • D Grow taller by the value of the new category
Show answer
Answer: Grow taller by the value of the new category
Why:

The height is the sum, so adding a component adds its value to the total.

Q37 The clearest reason to prefer a CLUSTER chart over a stacked one is that intermediate
  • A It never needs a key or legend
  • B Every bar is measured from the same zero line
  • C It can show more categories on the page
  • D It shows the totals more directly
Show answer
Answer: Every bar is measured from the same zero line
Why:

The shared baseline is what makes side-by-side bars comparable.

Q38 Family C spends ₹950 on housing and ₹1540 on education. On its stacked column beginner
  • A Neither length can be determined from the chart
  • B The two segments have the same length
  • C The housing segment is the longer of the two
  • D The education segment is the longer of the two
Show answer
Answer: The education segment is the longer of the two
Why:

1540 is greater than 950, so the education segment is longer wherever it is placed.

Q39 A reader wants to compare healthcare spending across the three families. The best chart is intermediate
  • A A chart showing only the totals
  • B A cluster chart grouped by category, so the three healthcare bars sit together
  • C A cluster chart grouped by family
  • D A stacked chart, so that healthcare can be seen sitting inside each of the totals
Show answer
Answer: A cluster chart grouped by category, so the three healthcare bars sit together
Why:

Grouping by category places those three bars side by side on a common base.

Q40 On the IUCN chart, the five column heights are 7851, 9618, 11212, 12630 and 14234. These are intermediate
  • A The number of mammals in each of the five years
  • B The yearly totals across all eight animal classes
  • C The increase from one year to the next
  • D The number of classes recorded in each year
Show answer
Answer: The yearly totals across all eight animal classes
Why:

The height of a stacked column is the total of all its segments.

Q41 Between 2016 and 2019 the IUCN total rises from 12630 to 14234. The increase is intermediate
  • A 1504 species
  • B 2604 species
  • C 1604 species
  • D 1704 species
Show answer
Answer: 1604 species
Why:

$14234 - 12630 = 1604$.

Q42 Which of these questions is HARDEST to answer from a stacked column chart? advanced
  • A Roughly what share of a total one category makes up
  • B Whether one group spends more in total than another
  • C How much one middle category changed between two groups
  • D Which group has the largest total
Show answer
Answer: How much one middle category changed between two groups
Why:

A middle segment lacks a common base across groups, which is exactly the comparison stacking makes hard.

Q43 Family A's six categories are 1940, 1700, 1280, 1200, 1770 and 535. The largest is beginner
  • A Housing, at ₹1940
  • B Education, at ₹1280
  • C Food, at ₹1700
  • D Healthcare, at ₹1770
Show answer
Answer: Housing, at ₹1940
Why:

1940 is the largest of the six.

Important short questions (10)

State what the full height of a stacked column represents, and give Family A's value.

It represents the total of all the segments. For Family A that is $1940 + 1700 + 1280 + 1200 + 1770 + 535 = 8425$.

Name the two ways this table could be drawn as a cluster-column chart, and say what each makes easy.

Clustering by family makes it easy to see one household across all six categories. Clustering by category makes it easy to compare one cost across the three households.

Explain why the second segment of a stacked column is harder to read than the first.

Only the first segment starts at zero. The second begins wherever the first ended, so its length must be found by subtracting two cumulative readings rather than read off as a height.

Find what share of Family A's total goes on housing.

$\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 0.230$, so 23.0%.

Family B spends nothing on recreation. Explain how this appears on a stacked chart and why the category is still shown.

It appears as a segment of zero length — the next segment begins exactly where the previous one ended. The category stays in the chart and its key because the other families do spend on it, and removing it would make the three columns impossible to compare.

Give the three family totals and say which family spends most and which least.

Family A ₹8425, Family B ₹7286, Family C ₹7040. Family A spends the most and Family C the least.

Explain why two segments in DIFFERENT stacked columns cannot be compared reliably by eye, and say what chart would allow it.

They begin at different heights, because the segments below them differ, so the eye has no common base against which to judge their lengths. A cluster chart grouped by category would place those bars side by side on the same zero line.

The IUCN totals are 7851, 9618, 11212, 12630 and 14234. Find the overall increase and express it as a percentage of the 2007 figure.

$14234 - 7851 = 6383$ species. As a percentage, $\dfrac{6383}{7851} = 0.813$, a rise of about 81%.

Does changing the ORDER of the segments change a stacked column? Explain.

It does not change the total, since addition does not depend on order. It does change which segment gains the zero baseline and is therefore easiest to read.

A reader wants to know which family spends most overall. Which chart serves them best, and why?

A stacked column chart, because the total for each family is the full height of its column and can be compared at a glance.

Long answer questions (4)

Answer each part in full. (i) State what the height of a stacked column represents. (ii) Find the totals for Families A, B and C. (iii) Explain one thing a stacked chart does better than a cluster chart, and one thing it does worse. (iv) Name the chart you would choose to compare healthcare spending across the three families.

(i) The total of all its segments. (ii) A: $1940 + 1700 + 1280 + 1200 + 1770 + 535 = 8425$. B: $1750 + 1546 + 1500 + 1280 + 1210 + 0 = 7286$. C: $950 + 1700 + 1540 + 1400 + 1300 + 150 = 7040$. (iii) Better: the totals can be compared directly as column heights, and a segment can be judged against its own whole. Worse: only the bottom segment starts at zero, so the others must be read as differences and cannot be compared across columns. (iv) A cluster chart grouped by category, so the three healthcare bars stand side by side on a common baseline.

Answer each part in full. (i) Find what share of Family A's total goes on housing, and what share goes on recreation. (ii) Explain how a reader could estimate both of these from a stacked chart without doing any arithmetic. (iii) Family B spends nothing on recreation. Explain what its segment looks like and why the category is still shown.

(i) Housing: $\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 23.0%$. Recreation: $\dfrac{535}{8425} = 6.4%$. (ii) By comparing the length of the segment with the length of the whole column by eye — housing takes a little under a quarter of the column, recreation a small sliver. (iii) It has zero length, so the segment above it begins exactly where the one below ended. The category stays in the chart because the other two families do spend on it and all three columns must show the same categories to be comparable.

Answer each part in full. (i) Describe the two ways of clustering a cluster-column chart of this table. (ii) For each, give one question it answers easily. (iii) Explain why neither can be called the better chart. (iv) State the one question a stacked chart answers better than either of them.

(i) Clustering by family gives three groups of six bars; clustering by category gives six groups of three bars. (ii) Clustering by family answers "what does Family A spend across everything?". Clustering by category answers "which family spent least on housing?" — Family C, at ₹950. (iii) Each makes one kind of comparison easy and the other awkward, so the better chart depends entirely on what the reader needs to find. (iv) Which family spends the most in total, since a stacked column shows the total as its full height.

Answer each part in full. (i) Explain how to read the length of a middle segment from a stacked column. (ii) Explain why the same segment cannot be compared by eye with the matching segment in a neighbouring column. (iii) Using the IUCN totals 7851 and 14234, find the increase and express it as a percentage. (iv) Say which of these three tasks a stacked chart handles best.

(i) Read where the segment ends and where it begins, and subtract: its length is the difference of two cumulative readings. (ii) Because the segments beneath it differ between columns, it starts at a different height in each, so there is no common base for the eye to use. (iii) $14234 - 7851 = 6383$, and $\dfrac{6383}{7851} = 0.813$, about an 81% rise. (iv) Part (iii) — the totals are the column heights, which is exactly what stacking shows well.

Flashcards (20)

What does the full height of a stacked column represent?
The total of all its segments — for Family A, ₹8425 of weekly spending.
What are the two ways of clustering a cluster-column chart of this table?
Cluster by family (six bars per family) or cluster by category (three bars per category).
When is a stacked bar chart the right choice?
When you want to compare totals while still seeing the components that make them up.
What does stacking cost you?
The common baseline. Only the bottom segment starts at zero, so every other segment is a difference rather than a height.
How do you read the length of a middle segment?
Subtract the reading where it begins from the reading where it ends.
What are the three family totals?
Family A ₹8425, Family B ₹7286, Family C ₹7040.
Which family spent least on housing, and how much?
Family C, at ₹950.
Which family spent most on healthcare?
Family A, at ₹1770.
What share of Family A's total goes on housing?
$\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 23.0\%$.
Family B spends nothing on recreation. How does that appear?
As a segment of zero length. The category is still in the chart.
Why can two segments in different stacks not be compared by eye?
They begin at different heights, so there is no common base to judge them against.
Which chart makes "compare one category across families" easiest?
A cluster chart grouped by category — the three bars sit together on the same zero line.
What does the TOP of the third segment tell you?
The running total of the first three segments, not the value of the third.
By how much do the IUCN totals rise between 2007 and 2019?
$14234 - 7851 = 6383$ species, a rise of about 81%.
Does the order of segments change a stacked column's total?
No. The sum is the same, but whichever category sits at the bottom gains the zero baseline.
Which family spent most on education?
Family C, at ₹1540.
What is the combined weekly spending of all three families?
$8425 + 7286 + 7040 = 22751$.
What can you estimate by comparing a segment with its whole column?
What fraction of the total that component makes up — by eye, without any arithmetic.
Which family spent least on transportation?
Family A, at ₹1200.
Which chart type should you choose first, and how do you decide?
Decide what the reader must find. Cluster for comparing across groups; stack for totals and shares.

Play this topic

  • Term and meaning
  • True or false
  • Fill in the blank
  • Unscramble the term

The 100% Stacked Bar: Comparing Shares Instead of Totals

Asking which family spends the smallest SHARE on healthcare is awkward on an ordinary stacked chart, because the columns are different heights and a share has to be judged against each one separately. Three pie charts fix that and introduce a new problem: comparing a slice in one pie with a slice in another is hard. Stretching every column to the same full length solves both at once, and the price is that the totals disappear completely.

Full explanation

A question the ordinary stack answers badly

Which family spends the smallest SHARE of its money on healthcare? On the stacked chart from the last topic every column is a different height, so each healthcare segment has to be judged against its own total before any comparison can begin. The answer is Family B at $16.6%$, against $21.0%$ for A and $18.5%$ for C — but nothing about the chart makes that easy to see.

Pie charts, and what they cost

A pie chart shows shares directly: Family A's housing slice really is $23.0%$ of its circle. Drawing one pie per family answers the question in principle.

In practice it does not. Comparing a slice in one pie with a slice in another means comparing two angles in two different circles, which the eye does badly. Three pies also take three times the space, and the categories appear in a different order around each one.

Stretching every column to the same length

The 100% stacked bar solves it. Every family's column is drawn to the SAME full length, and each segment takes the fraction of that length matching its share. Family A's housing segment occupies $23.0%$ of its bar and Family C's occupies $13.5%$ of its own, and because both bars are the same length those two lengths can be compared directly.

$$\text{segment length} = \dfrac{c_i}{T} \times \text{full length}$$

Now the healthcare question is read straight off: B's healthcare band is the shortest of the three.

What it gives up, which is everything about size

The ordinary stacked chart showed Family A spending ₹8425 against Family C's ₹7040. On a 100% chart those two bars are identical in length. The totals are gone entirely — a family spending ten times as much as another looks exactly the same.

So the three charts in this chapter answer three different questions:

chart what it shows best
cluster one category compared across families
stacked the totals, and a part against its own whole
100% stacked shares compared ACROSS families

Reading the three families

Family C spends the largest share on food, $24.1%$, while spending the least of the three in total — a reminder that a share says nothing about an amount. Family B puts nothing at all into recreation, so its band has zero length on every chart. And housing is where the two measures happen to agree: Family C spends the least on it both in rupees, ₹950, and as a share, $13.5%$. They need not agree, which is why the question must be read before the chart is chosen.

Watch out for these

Practice MCQs with answers (42)

Q1 On a 100% stacked bar chart, why is every bar the same length? beginner
  • A Each family happens to spend about the same amount in total
  • B Each bar stands for 100% of that family's own spending
  • C The chart always rounds every total to the nearest thousand rupees
  • D The longest bar is copied and the others are drawn to match it
Show answer
Answer: Each bar stands for 100% of that family's own spending
Why:

The bars show proportions, not amounts, so each one is the whole of its own family.

Q2 Which family spends the SMALLEST share of its money on healthcare? intermediate
  • A Family C, at 18.5%
  • B Family A, at 21.0%
  • C Family B, at 16.6%
  • D Families B and C are equal
Show answer
Answer: Family B, at 16.6%
Why:

Healthcare shares are 21.0%, 16.6% and 18.5%.

Q3 What does a 100% stacked bar chart give up completely? intermediate
  • A The order of the categories
  • B The ability to show a zero value
  • C The need for a key or legend
  • D Any indication of the totals
Show answer
Answer: Any indication of the totals
Why:

Families spending ₹8425 and ₹7040 draw identical bars; size is invisible.

Q4 Family A spends ₹1940 of ₹8425 on housing. Its share is intermediate
  • A 19.4%
  • B 23.0%
  • C 20.2%
  • D 26.1%
Show answer
Answer: 23.0%
Why:

$\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 0.230$.

Q5 Which family spends the LARGEST share on food? intermediate
  • A Family C, at 24.1%
  • B Families A and C are equal
  • C Family B, at 21.2%
  • D Family A, at 20.2%
Show answer
Answer: Family C, at 24.1%
Why:

Food shares are 20.2%, 21.2% and 24.1%.

Q6 Why is comparing one category across three separate pie charts difficult? intermediate
  • A The slices of a pie chart are not drawn to scale
  • B It means comparing angles in three different circles, which the eye judges badly
  • C Pie charts cannot show more than four categories at once
  • D Pie charts always place the categories in alphabetical order
Show answer
Answer: It means comparing angles in three different circles, which the eye judges badly
Why:

Each slice sits in its own circle with no shared edge to measure against.

Q7 The shares of one family on a 100% bar must add to beginner
  • A 100%
  • B The family's total spending
  • C 360 degrees
  • D The number of categories
Show answer
Answer: 100%
Why:

Every component is a fraction of the same whole, so the fractions sum to one.

Q8 Family C spends the largest share on food and the smallest total of the three. This shows that intermediate
  • A A large share does not mean a large amount
  • B Shares and amounts always move in the same direction
  • C Food must be more expensive for Family C than for the others
  • D Family C has made an arithmetic error in its budget
Show answer
Answer: A large share does not mean a large amount
Why:

C's 24.1% of ₹7040 is ₹1700, the same rupees as A's 20.2% of ₹8425.

Q9 A 100% stacked bar is the right chart when the question is about intermediate
  • A Totals compared across groups
  • B The exact rupee cost of one category
  • C Shares compared across different groups
  • D One value changing steadily over time
Show answer
Answer: Shares compared across different groups
Why:

Equal-length bars put every proportion on the same scale.

Q10 Family B spends nothing on recreation. On a 100% bar this appears as beginner
  • A A band of zero length
  • B The category being dropped from the chart
  • C A bar shorter than the other two
  • D A band shown below the axis
Show answer
Answer: A band of zero length
Why:

A zero share takes none of the bar; the bar itself still reaches 100%.

Q11 Which family spends the smallest share on housing? intermediate
  • A Family B, at 24.0%
  • B Family A, at 23.0%
  • C Family C, at 13.5%
  • D Families A and B are equal
Show answer
Answer: Family C, at 13.5%
Why:

Housing shares are 23.0%, 24.0% and 13.5%.

Q12 On a 100% bar of full length $L$, a component of value $c$ out of a total $T$ occupies intermediate
  • A $\dfrac{T}{c} \times L$
  • B $c \times T \times L$
  • C $\dfrac{c}{L} \times T$
  • D $\dfrac{c}{T} \times L$
Show answer
Answer: $\dfrac{c}{T} \times L$
Why:

The share of the whole is $\dfrac{c}{T}$, and the bar is $L$ long.

Q13 Family A's healthcare share is 21.0% and Family C's is 18.5%. In RUPEES, advanced
  • A They spend the same, because the bars are the same length
  • B C spends more, because its share sits lower on the bar
  • C A spends ₹1770 and C spends ₹1300, so A spends more
  • D Neither amount can be worked out from the shares alone
Show answer
Answer: A spends ₹1770 and C spends ₹1300, so A spends more
Why:

21.0% of 8425 is 1770; 18.5% of 7040 is 1300. The shares alone would not be enough without the totals.

Q14 Three pie charts and one 100% stacked bar show the same data. The bar is better for intermediate
  • A Comparing the same category across the three families
  • B Showing which category has the most subdivisions
  • C Displaying the three totals side by side
  • D Showing each family's shares on their own
Show answer
Answer: Comparing the same category across the three families
Why:

A pie shows one family's shares well; the bar aligns the same category across all three.

Q15 Family B's shares are 24.0, 21.2, 20.6, 17.6, 16.6 and 0.0. Their sum is beginner
  • A 116.6%
  • B 83.4%
  • C 95.0%
  • D 100.0%
Show answer
Answer: 100.0%
Why:

$24.0 + 21.2 + 20.6 + 17.6 + 16.6 + 0 = 100.0$.

Q16 Two families draw bars of exactly the same length on a 100% chart. This tells you intermediate
  • A That both families spend the same amount in total
  • B That one family spends exactly twice as much as the other
  • C That both families have the same number of categories
  • D Nothing at all about how much either family spends
Show answer
Answer: Nothing at all about how much either family spends
Why:

Every bar is the same length by construction, whatever the totals behind it.

Q17 Which chart would you choose to show that Family A spends ₹8425 and Family C ₹7040? intermediate
  • A A 100% stacked bar chart
  • B Three separate pie charts
  • C An ordinary stacked bar chart, where height is the total
  • D A 100% bar with the totals written underneath
Show answer
Answer: An ordinary stacked bar chart, where height is the total
Why:

Only the ordinary stack carries the totals as a readable height.

Q18 Family C's education share is 21.9% of ₹7040. In rupees that is advanced
  • A ₹1280
  • B ₹1540
  • C ₹1400
  • D ₹1500
Show answer
Answer: ₹1540
Why:

$0.219 \times 7040 = 1542$, which is the ₹1540 in the table, to rounding.

Q19 The healthcare bands on a 100% chart can be compared directly because intermediate
  • A Each band is printed with its percentage beside it
  • B Every bar has the same full length, so the bands share one scale
  • C Healthcare is always placed at the bottom of each bar
  • D The three families spend similar amounts on healthcare
Show answer
Answer: Every bar has the same full length, so the bands share one scale
Why:

A common length is what makes the lengths of the bands comparable.

Q20 Which of these questions can a 100% stacked bar NOT answer? intermediate
  • A Which family spends the most money in total
  • B Which family spends the largest share on food
  • C Whether housing takes about a quarter of Family A's money
  • D Which family spends nothing on recreation
Show answer
Answer: Which family spends the most money in total
Why:

Totals are exactly what the chart discards.

Q21 Assertion (A): Every bar on a 100% stacked chart has the same length. Reason (R): Each bar represents the whole of one family's spending. beginner
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both true, and R is why: 100% of anything fills the same bar.

Q22 Assertion (A): A 100% stacked bar does not show which family spends the most. Reason (R): The chart prints each family's total above its own bar. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is true but R is false
Why:

A is true, since the totals are not drawn on that chart at all. R is false - nothing on a 100% bar carries the totals, which is exactly why A holds.

Q23 Assertion (A): Family C has the largest food share and the smallest total. Reason (R): A 100% stacked bar draws every family to the same length. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both statements are true, but R is about how the chart is drawn and says nothing about why C combines a large share with a small total.

Q24 Assertion (A): Three pie charts compare a single category across families well. Reason (R): A pie chart shows the shares within one group clearly. intermediate
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A is false but R is true
Why:

A is false — comparing angles across separate circles is hard — while R is true in its own right.

Q25 Assertion (A): Family B's shares still add to 100% even though one of its six categories is missing. Reason (R): A component of zero takes up none of the whole. beginner
  • A Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • B Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • C A is true but R is false
  • D A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Why:

Both true, and R is the reason: the absent category claims no part of the bar, so the remaining five - 24.0, 21.2, 20.6, 17.6 and 16.6 - still total exactly 100.

Q26 A share is converted to rupees by multiplying it by intermediate
  • A The largest of the three totals
  • B The number of categories shown
  • C The combined total of all three families
  • D That family's own total
Show answer
Answer: That family's own total
Why:

A share is a fraction OF a particular whole, so it must be multiplied by that whole.

Q27 Family A's recreation share is 6.4%. The smallest share in the whole table belongs to advanced
  • A Family C's recreation, at 2.1%
  • B Family B's healthcare, at 16.6%
  • C Family C's housing, at 13.5%
  • D Family A's recreation, at 6.4%
Show answer
Answer: Family C's recreation, at 2.1%
Why:

Ignoring B's zero, the smallest non-zero share is C's recreation at 2.1%.

Q28 Two families have the same share for a category but different totals. Their rupee amounts are intermediate
  • A Equal, because the shares are equal
  • B Always within one per cent of each other
  • C Different, in proportion to their totals
  • D Impossible to compare without redrawing the chart
Show answer
Answer: Different, in proportion to their totals
Why:

The same fraction of two different wholes gives two different amounts.

Q29 The 100% stacked bar is sometimes described as an alternative to beginner
  • A A line graph of change over time
  • B A cluster-column chart
  • C A set of pie charts
  • D A simple table of figures
Show answer
Answer: A set of pie charts
Why:

Both show shares; the bar additionally lines up the same category across groups.

Q30 Family A spends 21.0% on healthcare and Family B 16.6%. The difference in SHARE is advanced
  • A 4.4 percentage points
  • B 4.4%
  • C ₹560
  • D 26.5%
Show answer
Answer: 4.4 percentage points
Why:

$21.0 - 16.6 = 4.4$, and a difference between two percentages is measured in percentage points.

Q31 If Family C's spending doubled in every category, its 100% bar would advanced
  • A Lose its smallest bands
  • B Become twice as long
  • C Look exactly the same
  • D Reorder its categories by size
Show answer
Answer: Look exactly the same
Why:

Doubling every component doubles the total too, so every share is unchanged.

Q32 Which category takes the largest share of Family B's spending? beginner
  • A Food, at 21.2%
  • B Transport, at 17.6%
  • C Education, at 20.6%
  • D Housing, at 24.0%
Show answer
Answer: Housing, at 24.0%
Why:

Family B's shares are 24.0, 21.2, 20.6, 17.6, 16.6 and 0.

Q33 A reader wants both the totals and the shares. The honest answer is advanced
  • A An ordinary stacked chart, which shows both equally well
  • B Two charts are needed, because no single one shows both well
  • C A 100% bar with the totals printed above each bar
  • D Three pie charts drawn to different sizes
Show answer
Answer: Two charts are needed, because no single one shows both well
Why:

Each chart in this chapter trades one for the other; combining them is a design choice, not a chart type.

Q34 Family C's transport share is 19.9% and Family B's is 17.6%. In rupees C spends advanced
  • A An amount that cannot be found from the chart
  • B ₹1400 against B's ₹1280, so C spends more
  • C The same as B, since the shares are close
  • D ₹1280 against B's ₹1400, so C spends less
Show answer
Answer: ₹1400 against B's ₹1280, so C spends more
Why:

$0.199 \times 7040 = 1400$ and $0.176 \times 7286 = 1282$.

Q35 On a 100% bar, a band that looks twice as long as another band in the SAME bar means intermediate
  • A That category costs twice as many rupees in every family
  • B That category takes twice the share of the family's spending
  • C The two categories have been swapped in the key
  • D The bar has been drawn to the wrong scale
Show answer
Answer: That category takes twice the share of the family's spending
Why:

Within one bar the lengths are proportional to that family's own shares.

Q36 Which family has the most even spread of spending across its categories? advanced
  • A Family A, whose shares run from 6.4% to 23.0%
  • B Family B, whose shares run from 0% to 24.0%
  • C All three have exactly the same spread
  • D Family C, whose shares run from 2.1% to 24.1%
Show answer
Answer: Family C, whose shares run from 2.1% to 24.1%
Why:

Ignoring recreation, C's five remaining shares sit between 13.5% and 24.1%, the narrowest band of the three.

Q37 The percentages in each pie chart of Fig. 10.3 add to beginner
  • A 360% for each family
  • B A different total for each family
  • C 100% for each family separately
  • D 100% across all three families together
Show answer
Answer: 100% for each family separately
Why:

A pie shows the whole of one family, so its slices total 100%.

Q38 Converting Family A's 15.2% education share to rupees gives advanced
  • A ₹1540
  • B ₹1200
  • C ₹1500
  • D ₹1280
Show answer
Answer: ₹1280
Why:

$0.152 \times 8425 = 1281$, the ₹1280 in the table, to rounding.

Q39 The main reason to prefer a 100% bar over three pies is that intermediate
  • A It shows the totals as well as the shares
  • B It uses fewer colours than three pie charts
  • C The same category can be compared across the groups
  • D It can display a zero value and a pie chart cannot
Show answer
Answer: The same category can be compared across the groups
Why:

Aligning the same band across equal-length bars is what the pies cannot do.

Q40 Family B has no recreation spending. Its five remaining shares must therefore intermediate
  • A Add to less than 100%
  • B Still add to 100%
  • C Each be larger than 20%
  • D Be redrawn as a pie chart instead
Show answer
Answer: Still add to 100%
Why:

$24.0 + 21.2 + 20.6 + 17.6 + 16.6 = 100.0$. A zero component takes nothing from the whole.

Q41 Across the three families, housing shares are 23.0%, 24.0% and 13.5%. The range is intermediate
  • A 10.5 percentage points
  • B 60.5 percentage points
  • C 24.0 percentage points
  • D 13.5 percentage points
Show answer
Answer: 10.5 percentage points
Why:

$24.0 - 13.5 = 10.5$.

Q42 A 100% stacked bar chart is MOST misleading if a reader assumes that advanced
  • A The shares of each bar add to 100%
  • B A zero component takes none of the bar
  • C The bands within one bar are proportional to its shares
  • D Equal bar lengths mean equal spending
Show answer
Answer: Equal bar lengths mean equal spending
Why:

That assumption is exactly the information the chart has removed.

Important short questions (10)

Explain why every bar on a 100% stacked chart has the same length.

Because each bar represents the whole of one family's spending — 100% of it — and 100% of anything fills the same bar. The differences appear inside the bar, in the shares, not in its length.

State which family spends the smallest share on healthcare, giving all three figures.

Family B, at 16.6%. Family C is 18.5% and Family A is 21.0%.

Explain why comparing one category across three pie charts is harder than across a 100% stacked bar.

In three pies the category appears as an angle in three separate circles, with no common edge or scale to judge against. On a 100% bar the bars are the same length, so the three bands lie on one scale and their lengths compare directly.

Find Family C's housing share, and say how it compares with the other two.

$\dfrac{950}{7040} = 13.5%$, which is much the smallest — Family A is 23.0% and Family B 24.0%.

Family C has the largest food share of the three and the smallest total. Explain how both can be true, with figures.

A share is a proportion of a family's own spending, not an amount. C's 24.1% of ₹7040 is ₹1700 — exactly the same rupees as Family A's 20.2% of ₹8425. The share is larger because C's total is smaller.

State what a 100% stacked bar chart discards, and give the figures that show it.

It discards the totals completely. Family A spends ₹8425 and Family C ₹7040, yet both bars are drawn to the same length, so nothing in the chart distinguishes them by size.

Family B spends nothing on recreation. Show that its remaining five shares still account for the whole bar.

$24.0 + 21.2 + 20.6 + 17.6 + 16.6 = 100.0$. A component of zero takes none of the whole, so the remaining five still sum to 100% and the bar still reaches its full length.

If every one of Family C's six amounts doubled, what would happen to its 100% bar? Justify your answer.

Nothing would change. Doubling each component doubles the total as well, so every share $\dfrac{2c}{2T} = \dfrac{c}{T}$ is unchanged, and the bar is drawn from the shares alone.

Convert Family A's healthcare share of 21.0% into rupees, and explain what extra information you needed.

$0.210 \times 8425$, which is ₹1770. The share alone is not enough; you need Family A's own total, which the 100% chart does not show.

A reader wants both the totals and the shares from one chart. Explain the difficulty.

The ordinary stacked chart shows totals as heights but makes shares awkward to compare across families; the 100% chart compares shares but removes the totals. Each buys one by selling the other, so two charts are the honest answer.

Long answer questions (4)

Answer each part in full. (i) Explain why every bar on a 100% stacked chart is the same length. (ii) Give the three healthcare shares and name the smallest. (iii) Convert that smallest share into rupees, stating what you needed to do so. (iv) State one thing this chart cannot show at all.

(i) Each bar represents 100% of one family's spending, so all three fill the same length; the differences lie inside the bar. (ii) A 21.0%, B 16.6%, C 18.5%. Family B is smallest. (iii) $0.166 \times 7286$, which is ₹1210. This needed Family B's own total, which the chart does not provide. (iv) The totals. Families spending ₹8425 and ₹7040 draw identical bars.

Answer each part in full. (i) Explain why three pie charts compare one category across families poorly. (ii) Explain how the 100% stacked bar fixes this. (iii) Name one thing the pie charts still do perfectly well. (iv) Give the food shares of all three families and name the largest.

(i) The category is an angle in three separate circles, with no shared edge or scale, and the eye judges angles across circles badly. (ii) Every bar is the same length, so the bands for one category lie on a single scale and their lengths can be compared directly. (iii) Showing the shares WITHIN one family — a pie makes a single group's proportions very clear. (iv) A 20.2%, B 21.2%, C 24.1%; Family C's is the largest.

Answer each part in full. (i) Show that Family C has the largest food share and the smallest total. (ii) Convert C's food share to rupees and compare it with Family A's food spending. (iii) Explain what this shows about shares and amounts. (iv) Name the chart you would use if the question were about amounts rather than shares.

(i) C's food share is $\dfrac{1700}{7040} = 24.1%$, the largest of 20.2%, 21.2% and 24.1%; C's total of ₹7040 is the smallest of ₹8425, ₹7286 and ₹7040. (ii) $0.241 \times 7040 = 1700$, which is exactly what Family A spends on food as well. (iii) A larger share does not mean a larger amount. The same rupees are a bigger slice of a smaller budget. (iv) A cluster-column chart grouped by category, which compares the actual amounts on a common baseline.

Answer each part in full. (i) State the formula for the length of a component on a 100% bar of full length $L$. (ii) Family B spends nothing on recreation. Show that its other five shares still total 100%. (iii) Explain what happens to a 100% bar if every component of that family doubles. (iv) State the single most misleading assumption a reader can make about such a chart.

(i) $\ell = \dfrac{c}{T} \times L$, where $c$ is the component and $T$ the family's total. (ii) $24.0 + 21.2 + 20.6 + 17.6 + 16.6 = 100.0$. A zero component takes none of the whole. (iii) Nothing changes: $\dfrac{2c}{2T} = \dfrac{c}{T}$, so every share and therefore every band is identical. (iv) That equal bar lengths mean equal spending. That is exactly the information the chart has removed.

Flashcards (20)

Why is every bar on a 100% stacked chart the same length?
Each bar represents 100% of that family's own spending, so they all reach the same end.
What does a 100% stacked bar give up?
The totals entirely. Families spending ₹8425 and ₹7040 draw identical bars.
Which family spends the smallest share on healthcare?
Family B, at 16.6%, against 18.5% for C and 21.0% for A.
Which family spends the largest share on food?
Family C, at 24.1% — while having the smallest total of the three.
Why is comparing a slice across three pie charts hard?
It means comparing angles in three separate circles, with no shared edge for the eye to measure against.
How do you turn a share back into rupees?
Multiply it by that family's own total — a share is a fraction OF a particular whole.
What is Family A's housing share?
$\dfrac{1940}{8425} = 23.0\%$.
What is the length of a component on a 100% bar of full length $L$?
$\dfrac{c}{T} \times L$, where $c$ is the component and $T$ the family's total.
Family B spends nothing on recreation. What happens to its bar?
The recreation band has zero length, but the bar still reaches 100%.
Do the shares of one family add to 100%?
Always. Every component is a fraction of the same whole.
Which family spends the smallest share on housing?
Family C, at 13.5%, against 23.0% and 24.0%.
Two families show the same share for a category. Are the amounts equal?
No — the same fraction of two different totals gives two different amounts.
Which chart shows the totals: ordinary stacked, or 100% stacked?
The ordinary stacked chart. The 100% version discards them.
If every one of Family C's categories doubled, what would its 100% bar look like?
Exactly the same. Doubling the components doubles the total, so every share is unchanged.
What is the main advantage of a 100% bar over three pie charts?
The same category can be compared across the groups, because the bands share one scale.
What is the range of the housing shares across the three families?
$24.0 - 13.5 = 10.5$ percentage points.
What does a difference between two percentages get measured in?
Percentage points. A rise from 16.6% to 21.0% is 4.4 percentage points.
Which three questions do the three charts in this chapter answer?
Cluster: one category across families. Stacked: the totals. 100% stacked: shares across families.
What is Family C's education share, and what is it in rupees?
21.9% of ₹7040, which is ₹1540.
What is the most misleading assumption a reader can make about a 100% bar?
That equal bar lengths mean equal spending. That is precisely the information the chart removes.

Play this topic

  • Term and meaning
  • True or false
  • Fill in the blank
  • Unscramble the term

Class 9 Mathematics Chapter 10 — frequently asked questions

Explain why the average of two group averages is not always the average of the whole collection.

Averaging the two averages gives each group equal say, but a group with more values contributes more to the total. Each average must therefore be weighted by the size of its own group.

A class has 20 boys averaging 48 kg and 30 girls averaging 43 kg. Find the average mass of the class.

$\dfrac{(48 \times 20) + (43 \times 30)}{50} = \dfrac{2250}{50} = 45$ kg.

State the one condition under which averaging a set of averages is correct, and explain briefly why.

All the groups must be the same size. Writing the combined average as $\dfrac{ap + bp + cp}{3p}$ shows the common size $p$ cancels, leaving $\dfrac{a + b + c}{3}$.

State what the full height of a stacked column represents, and give Family A's value.

It represents the total of all the segments. For Family A that is $1940 + 1700 + 1280 + 1200 + 1770 + 535 = 8425$.

Name the two ways this table could be drawn as a cluster-column chart, and say what each makes easy.

Clustering by family makes it easy to see one household across all six categories. Clustering by category makes it easy to compare one cost across the three households.

Explain why the second segment of a stacked column is harder to read than the first.

Only the first segment starts at zero. The second begins wherever the first ended, so its length must be found by subtracting two cumulative readings rather than read off as a height.

Explain why every bar on a 100% stacked chart has the same length.

Because each bar represents the whole of one family's spending — 100% of it — and 100% of anything fills the same bar. The differences appear inside the bar, in the shares, not in its length.

State which family spends the smallest share on healthcare, giving all three figures.

Family B, at 16.6%. Family C is 18.5% and Family A is 21.0%.

Explain why comparing one category across three pie charts is harder than across a 100% stacked bar.

In three pies the category appears as an angle in three separate circles, with no common edge or scale to judge against. On a 100% bar the bars are the same length, so the three bands lie on one scale and their lengths compare directly.

All Class 9 Mathematics chapters

All Mathematics chapters · Every Class 9 subject · The whole NCERT library

Study this chapter properly, free

Everything above is on this page to read. In the Veda app the same chapter becomes spaced-repetition flashcards, timed tests that mark themselves, Veda Bites you can swipe, and games — with your progress tracked topic by topic.

Get Veda free